Ozy Diva Ersya


he application of trade facilitation needs further analyses in the context of Indonesian’s law. So far Indonesia does not yet ratify the trade facilitation agreement. In one hand the trade facilitation is a compulsory requirement that must be fulfilled by a state, in other hands the state does not provide a legal instrument. The consequence is legal uncertainty to those parties who want to invest their money in Indonesia. The trade facilitation will also in line with ASEAN programs. Those programs have same purposes to fasten the movement of goods and services by providing legal certainty on trade facilitation foundations. The WTO TFA can be used as ‘soft-law’ for Indonesian legal framework to apply trade facilitation enhancement, although it is not yet ratified by Indonesia. The WTO TFA will easily appropriate and have legal force if the implementation of the WTO TFA into Indonesian national legal structure is also noticeable.


Keyword: trade facilitation, legal perspective, ASEAN programs

Full Text:



Andrew Grainger, ‘The WTO Trade Facilitation Agreement: Consulting the Private Sector’ (2014) 48(6) Journal of World Trade 1167-1188.

------------, ‘Trade Facilitation: A Conceptual Review’ (2011) Journal of World Trade 39-62.

------------, ‘Trade Facilitation’ in Kenneth Heydon and Stephen Woolcock (eds), The Ashgate Research Companion to International Trade Policy (Ashgate Publishing 2012),

Antonia Elliason, ‘The Trade Facilitation Agreement-Episode IV: A new Hope for the WTO’ (2015) 14 World Trade Review 661

Blackwell Publishers, Hans-Michael Wolffgang and Edward Kafeero, ‘Old Wine in New Skins: Analysis of the Trade Facilitation Agreement vis-à -vis the Revised Kyoto Convention’ (2014) 8(2) World Customs Journal 27-38.

Brian Rankin Staples, ‘Trade Facilitation’ (October 19, 1998. Draft)

Carolin Eve Bolhofer, ‘Trade Facilitation-WTO Law and its Revision to Facilitate Global Trade in Goods’ (2007) 2(11/12) Global Trade and Customs Journal 385-391.

David Widdowson, ‘International Trade Facilitation: The Customs Imperative’ (2005) Research presented at the APEC Workshop on the WTO Trade Facilitation Negotiations, Kuala Lumpur

Deborah Elms, ‘After Bali: What Happens Next with Asian Trade Facilitation’ (2014) 9 Asian Journal WTO and International Health Law Policy 429-444.

Faizel Ismail, ‘An Assessment of the WTO Doha Round July-December 2008 Collapse’ (2009) 8(4) World Trade Review 579-605.

Heng Wang, ‘The Agreement on Trade Facilitation and its Implications: An Interpretative Persepective’ (2014) 9 Asian Journal WTO and International Health Law Policy 445-476

Hikmahanto Juwana, ‘Dua Kewajiban Dalam Proses Ratifikasi Perjanjian International: Kewajiban Memastikan Keselarasan dengan Konstitusi dan Kewajiban Mentransformasikan ke dalam Hukum Nasional’ (2016) Research presented in Legal Workshop at Headquarter of Indonesian Customs in Jakarta

James Scott and Rorden Wilkinson, ‘The Poverty of the Doha Round and Least Developed Countries (2011) 32(4) Third World Quarterly 611-627.

Joseph Michael Finger and John S. Wilson, ‘Implementing Trade Facilitation Agreement in the WTO: What Makes Sense?’ (2007) 12(3) Pacific Economic Review 335-355

Joseph Michael Finger, ‘The WTO Trade Facilitation Agreement: Form without Substance Again?’ (2014) 48(6) Journal of World Trade 1279–1287.

Joseph Michael Finger, ‘Trade Facilitation: The Role of a WTO Agreement’ (2008) ECIPE Working Research No. 1, Gerard McLinden, ‘Needs, Priorities and Costs Associated with Technical Assistance and Capacity Building for Implementation of a WTO Trade Facilitation Agreement: A Comparative Study Based on Six Developing Countries’ (2006) World Bank Working Research, November, 1-5, 9-35 in Jean-Christophe Maur and John S. Wilson (eds), Trade Costs and Facilitation: Open Trade and Economic Development, Vol II (Edward Elgar Publishing Limited 2011).

Mary E Footer, 'The (Re)turn to Soft Law in Reconciling the Antinomies of WTO Law’, (2010) 11(2) Melbourne Journal of International Law, 241-276.

Monica Alina Mustra, ‘Chapter 3: Border Management Modernization and the Trade Supply Chain’ in Gerard Mclinden, Enrique Fanta, David Widdowson, and Tom Doyle (eds), Border Management Modernization (The World Bank 2011).

Nora Neufeld, ‘The Long and Winding Road: How WTO Members Finally Reached A Trade Facilitation Agreement’ (2014) The WTO Staff Working Research ERSD-2014-06

Patrick A. Masserlin and Jamel Zarrouk, ‘Trade Facilitation: Technical Regulations and Customs Procedures’ (2000)

Rorden Wilkinson, ‘Language, Power and Multilateral Trade Negotiations’ (2009) 16(4) Review of International Political Economy 597-619.

Rorden Wilkinson, ‘The WTO in Hongkong: What it really means for the Doha Development Agenda’ (2006) 11(2) New Political Economy 291-304.

Saloni Khanderia-Yadav, ‘Implications of the World Trade Organisation’s Agreement on Trade Facilitation for Emerging Economies’ (2015) 12(1) Manchester Journal of International Economic Law 33-58.

Shintaro Hamanaka, ‘World Trade Organization Agreement on Trade Facilitation: Assessing the Level of Ambition and Likely Impacts’ (2014) 9 Global Trade and Customs Journal, Kluwer Law International, 341-351

Yan Duval, ‘Trade Facilitation Beyond the Doha Round of Negotiations’ (2007) Asia Pacific Research and Training Network on Trade, Working Research Series no. 50.

Yuen Pau Woo, Trade Facilitation in the World Trade Organisation: Singapore to Doha and Beyond’ 270-279 in Will Martin and Mari Pangestu (eds), Options for Global Trade Reform: A View from the Asia-Pacific (Cambridge University Press 2003)

Yukyun “Harry†Shin, ‘New Round and Trade Facilitation: Proposing a Tentative Draft Agreement on Trade Facilitation Measures’ (2001) 35(2) Journal of World Trade 229-252.

Yukyun “Harry†Shin, ‘Trade Facilitation and WTO Rules: For a Better Harmonised Customs System’ (1999) 33(4) Journal of World Trade 131-142

Website:> accessed 4 August 2016> accessed 8 August 2016> accessed 6 August 2016> accessed 7 August 2016> accessed 4 August 2016



  • There are currently no refbacks.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Flag Counter