Why Not Indonesia an Islamic State? Constitutional Debate Concerning Religion-State Relation in A Muslim Majority Country

Andy Omara

doi:10.22373/sjhk.v8i1.15889

Why Not Indonesia an Islamic State? Constitutional Debate Concerning Religion-State Relation in A Muslim Majority Country

Andy Omara

Abstract

When Muslims are majority in a particular country, it is often linked to the adoption of Islam as the state official religion or Islam as the identity of the state i.e. “Islamic State.” Yet, this is not the case of Indonesia. Why did not the Indonesian constitutional drafters declare Indonesia as an Islamic state or at least recognize Islam as the state official religion in the first Constitution despite the fact that Indonesia is a Muslim majority country? What explains the above fact? This paper aims to answer these two important questions by employing two constitutional law approaches: constitutional history and constitutional deferral. Constitutional history aims to understand the original intentions of the framers of the first Constitution through studying the minutes of the 1^st Constitution. Constitutional deferral concept is used to explain the formulation of state-religion relation in the provisions of the first Constitution. This paper argues the fact that the constitutional drafters did not expressly state Islam as the state official religion in the Constitution did not mean that they overlooked to discuss such an important topic, rather because they had diverse views on how to include religion-state relation in the constitution. The sharp ideological difference among constitutional drafters is likely the cause of the adoption of constitutional deferral -a method of drafting constitutional through somewhat general and abstract provisions. The use of constitutional deferral is favorable because it opens more opportunity among constitutional drafters to achieve consensus and get things done. In practice, Indonesia is not a country officially based on Islam, but substantially Islamic values live in Indonesia. This article contributes to the study of the relationship between state and religion in Indonesia, regarding the current and future background and dialectics.

Keywords

State and religion, constitutional deferral, constitutional making

Full Text:

PDF

References

Journals and Books

Ackerman, Bruce A. We the People. 1: Foundations. 1. Harvard Univ. Press paperback ed. Cambridge, Mass.: Belknap Press of Harvard Univ. Press, 1993.

Ahmad Syafii Maarif. Islam Dan Masalah Kenegaraan : Studi Tentang Percaturan Dalam Konstituante. Cet. 1. Jakarta: LP3ES, 1985.

Anshari, Endang Saifuddin. Piagam Jakarta, 22 Juni 1945: Sebuah Konsensus Nasional tentang Dasar Negara Republik Indonesia (1945-1959). Edisi 3. Jakarta: Gema Insani Press, 1997.

Bachtiar, Hasnan, and Zakiyuddin Baidhawy. ‘Theologising Democracy in the Context of Muhammadiyah’s Ijtihād’. Indonesian Journal of Islam and Muslim Societies 12, no. 1 (4 June 2022). https://doi.org/10.18326/ijims.v12i1.165-200.

Bagus Prihantoro Nugroho. ‘Kasman Singodimedjo Dan Penghapusan 7 Kata Piagam Jakarta’. Jakarta: detikNews, 11 August 2018. https://news.detik.com/berita/d-4293369/kasman-singodimedjo-dan-penghapusan-7-kata-piagam-jakarta.

Bâli, Aslı Ü., and Hanna Lerner, eds. Constitution Writing, Religion and Democracy. 1st ed. Cambridge University Press, 2017. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781107707443.

Bogdanor, Vernon and Policy Studies Institute, eds. Constitutions in Democratic Politics. Aldershot, Hants, England ; Brookfield, Vt., USA: Gower, 1988.

Cecep Supriadi. ‘Relasi Islam Dan Negara: Wacana Keislaman Dan Keindonesiaan’. Kalimah: Jurnal Studi Agama Dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 13 No. 1 (March 2015). http://dx.doi.org/10.21111/klm.v13i1.285.

Choudhry, Sujit, and Mark Tushnet. ‘Participatory Constitution-Making: Introduction’. International Journal of Constitutional Law 18, no. 1 (21 May 2020). https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/moaa014.

Dixon, R., and T. Ginsburg. ‘Deciding Not to Decide: Deferral in Constitutional Design’. International Journal of Constitutional Law 9, no. 3–4 (1 October 2011). https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/mor041.

Elisabeth Zoller. ‘Laïcité in the United States or The Separation of Church and State in Pluralist Society’. Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies Volume 13, no. Issue 2, Article 10 (2006). https://www.repository.law.indiana.edu/ijgls/vol13/iss2/10.

Elster, Jon. ‘Forces and Mechanisms in the Constitution-Making Process’. Duke Law Journal 45, no. 2 (November 1995). https://doi.org/10.2307/1372906.

Hering, B. B. Soekarno: Founding Father of Indonesia, 1901-1945. Verhandelingen van Het Koninklijk Instituut Voor Taal-, Land- En Volkenkunde 192. Leiden: KITLV Press, 2002.

Hirschl, Ran. Constitutional Theocracy. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press, 2010.

Künkler, Mirjam. Constitutionalism, Islamic Law, and Religious Freedom in Post-Independence Indonesia. Chapter 8 in Asli Bali and Hanna Lerner (eds.): Constitution Writing, Religion and Democracy. UK: Cambridge University Press, 2017. https://ssrn.com/abstract=3258416.

Kusuma, Ananda B. Lahirnya Undang-Undang Dasar 1945: memuat salinan dokumen otentik Badan Oentoek Menyelidiki Oesaha Persiapan Kemerdekaan. Depok: Badan Penerbit, Fakultas Hukum, Universitas Indonesia, 2004.

Landau, David E., and Hanna Lerner, eds. Comparative Constitution Making. Research Handbooks in Comparative Constitutional Law. Cheltenham, UK ; Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar Publishing, 2019.

Maarif, Ahmad Syafii. Islam, Humanity and the Indonesian Identity : Reflections on History. Translated by George A. Fowler. Leiden University Press, 2018. https://doi.org/10.24415/9789087283018.

Mancini, Susanna, ed. Constitutions and Religion. Research Handbooks in Comparative Constitutional Law Series. Cheltenham, UK ; Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar Publishing Limited, 2020.

McWhinney, Edward. Constitution-Making: Principles, Process, Practice. Toronto [Ontario]: University of Toronto Press, 2019.

Miftahuddin, Miftahuddin, and Dudung Abdurahman. ‘Pragmatism-Accommodative Political Patterns of Al-Irsyad During the Reign of President Soekarno, 1945-1965’. Journal Of Indonesian Islam 17, No. 1 (2023). https://doi.org/10.15642/JIIS.2023.17.1.189-212.

M.P.B. Manus., et.al. Tokoh-Tokoh Badan Penyelidik Usaha-Usaha Persiapan Kemerdekaan Indonesia. Jakarta: Departemen Pendidikan dan Kebuadayaan, 1993.

Mujani, Saiful, et.al., ‘Islamism and Muslim Support for Islamist Movement Organizations: Evidence from Indonesia’. Studia Islamika 30, no. 1 (2023). https://doi.org/10.36712/sdi.v30i1.33369.

Nakamura, Mitsuo. ‘Prof. H. Abdul Kahar Muzakkir and The Development of Islamic Reformist Movement in Indonesia’. Afkaruna 15, no. 2 (2019). https://doi.org/10.18196/AIIJIS.2019.0103.

Nurdin, Abidin, “Dialectics in Relationship Between Religion and State: A Correlation of Religious Principles and Ideals of Law in Indonesia,” Al-Bayyinah: Journal of Islamic Law 4, No. 1 (2020). DOI : 10.35673/al-bayyinah.v4i1.758.

Pew Research Center. ‘Many Countries Favor Specific Religions, Officially or Unofficially’. USA: Pew Research Center, 3 October 2017. https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2017/10/03/many-countries-favor-specific-religions-officially-or-unofficially/.

Safa’at, Muchamad Ali. ‘The Roles of the Indonesian Constitutional Court in Determining State-Religion Relations’. Constitutional Review 8, no. 1 (2022). https://doi.org/10.31078/consrev815.

Salim, Arskal, Challenging the Secular State: The Islamization of Law in Modern Indonesia. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press, 2008.

Scott, Rachel M. Recasting Islamic Law: Religion and The Nation-State in Egyptian Constitution Making. Ithaca London: Cornell University Press, 2021.

Shah, Dian A H. ‘The Law and Politics of Religion and Constitutional Practices in Asia’. Asian Journal of Comparative Law 13, no. 2 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1017/asjcl.2019.3.

Syahbandir, Mahdi, et.al., “State and Islamic Law: A Study of Legal Politics on Zakat as a Tax Deduction in Aceh,” Ahkam: Jurnal Ilmu Syariah 22, No. 1 (2022). DOI: 10.15408/ajis.v22i1.26200.

Sodiqin, Ali, and Anwar M Radiamoda. ‘The Dynamics of Islamic Constitution: From the Khilāfah Period to the Nation-State’. JIL: Journal of Islamic Law 2, no. 2 (2021). https://doi.org/10.24260/jil.v2i2.241.

Syarif, Mujar Ibnu. ‘Spirit Piagam Jakarta Dalam Undang-Undang Dasar 1945’. Jurnal Cita Hukum 4, No. 1 (2016). https://doi.org/10.15408/jch.v4i1.3568.

Internet Data

Ahmad Jilul Qurani Farid. ‘Haedar Nashir Singgung Penghapusan 7 Kata Di Piagam Jakarta’. Jakarta: Gatra.com, 16 August 2019. https://www.gatra.com/news-438079-politik-haedar-nashir-singgung-penghapusan-7-kata-di-piagam-jakarta.html.

Dawood Ahmed. Religion–State Relations. Second Edition. Sweden: International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance (International IDEA), 2017. https://www.idea.int/sites/default/files/publications/religion-state-relations-primer.pdf.

Iswara N Raditya. ‘Sejarah Kandasnya Gagasan Negara Islam Ala Ki Bagus Hadikusumo’. Jakarta: Tirto.id, 16 May 2019. https://tirto.id/sejarah-kandasnya-gagasan-negara-islam-ala-ki-bagus-hadikusumo-dD9m.

Lukman Hadi Subroto, Tri Indriawati. ‘Biografi Moh Hatta, Wakil Presiden Pertama Indonesia’. Jakarta: Kompas.com, 23 August 2022. https://www.kompas.com/stori/read/2022/08/23/120000479/biografi-moh-hatta-wakil-presiden-pertama-indonesia?page=all.

Nathan J. Brown. ‘Mrs. Lincoln’s Egyptian Constitution. Washington DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 20 August 2013. https://carnegieendowment.org/2013/08/20/mrs.-lincoln-s-egyptian-constitution-pub-52722.

Nibras Nada Nailufar. ‘Piagam Jakarta: Isi Dan Kontroversinya’. Jakarta: Kompas.com, 2 July 2020. https://www.kompas.com/skola/read/2020/02/07/100000769/piagam-jakarta-isi-dan-kontroversinya?page=all.

Tim Redaksi Hukumonline. ‘Jalan Mr. Latuharhary, Mengenang Tokoh Hukum Dari Saparua’. Jakarta: Hukum Online, 22 September 2009. https://www.hukumonline.com/berita/a/jalan-mr-latuharhary-mengenang-tokoh-hukum-dari-saparua-hol23186/.

Tushnet, M. ‘Constitution-Making: An Introduction’. Texas Law Review 91 (2013).

Virgina Maulita Putri. ‘Profil AA Maramis, Perumus Piagam Jakarta Yang Jadi Pahlawan Nasional’. Jakarta: detikNews, 11 August 2019. https://news.detik.com/berita/d-4777278/profil-aa-maramis-perumus-piagam-jakarta-yang-jadi-pahlawan-nasional.

Weithman, Paul J. Religion, and Contemporary Liberalism. Notre Dame (Ind.): University of Notre Dame press, 2009.

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.22373/sjhk.v8i1.15889