English
Doubts on the Hadith of Al-Thaqalayn in Sunni and Shia Perspective
Abstract
The Hadith of al-Thaqalayn is one of the most significant hadiths in Islamic literature, particularly within Sunni and Shia traditions. This hadith states that the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) left behind two important things: the Qur'an and the Ahlul Bayt. This study examines various versions of the Hadith of al-Thaqalayn to determine its authenticity, interpretation, and implications for leadership in Islam. By comparing primary sources such as Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim and Uṣūl al-Kāfī, along with secondary literature, this research employs content analysis to identify textual variations, address doubts, and assess scholarly criticism of the Hadith of al-Thaqalayn. The findings reveal that despite differences in interpretation, both Sunni and Shia traditions emphasize the importance of adhering to the Qur'an and the Sunnah as the primary guides. The study also highlights the complexity of assessing the reliability of hadiths, demonstrating that even though some chains of transmission may be considered weak, the core message of adhering to the Qur'an and the teachings of the Prophet Muhammad remains vital. Additionally, the analysis discusses theological debates regarding the role of the Ahlul Bayt and provides a more comprehensive understanding of the Hadith of al-Thaqalayn within the context of Islamic scholarly tradition.
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Al-Albānī, Muḥammad Nāṣir Al-Dīn, Silsilat Al-Aḥādīth Al-Ṣaḥīḥah Wa Shay’ Min Fiqhiha Wa Fawāidihā (Maktabat Al-Ma‘ārif Li Al-Nashr Wa Al-Tawzī‘, 2002), IV
Al-Andalusī, ‘Alī Ibn Aḥmad Ibn Sa‘īd Ibn Ḥazm, Al-Iḥkām Fī Uṣūl Al-Aḥkām (Dār Al-Āfāq Al-Jadīdah, 1983)
Al-‘Asqalānī, Abū al-Faḍl Aḥmad ibn Ḥajar, Tahdhīb Al-Tahdhīb, Jilid 1 (Mu’assasah Al-Risalah, 2014)
———, Taqrīb Al-Tahdhīb, Jilid 1 (Daar al-Rasyid, 1986)
Al-Bayāḍī, ‘Alī Ibn Yūnus Al-‘Āmilī Al-Nabāṭī, Al-Ṣirāṭ al-Mustaqīm Ilā Mustaḥiqqī Al-Taqdīm (Maṭba’at Al-Ḥaydarī), III
Al-Bayhaqī, Abū Bakr Aḥmad ibn al-Ḥusayn, Shu‘ab al-Īmān, Jilid 4 (Maktabah Al-Rushd, 2003)
Al-Dhahabī, Shams al-Dīn Abū ‘Abdillāh, Al-Kāshif Fi Ma’rifati Man Lahu Riwāyah Fi al-Kutub al-Sittah, Jilid 1 (Daar al-Qiblah Li al-Thaqafah al-Islamiyyah – Mu’assasah ‘Ulum Al-Quran, 1992)
———, Mīzān Al-I‘tidāl Fī Naqd Al-Rijāl (Dār Al-Ma‘rifah Li Al-Ṭibā‘ah Wa Al-Nashr, 1963)
Al-Habsyi, Ali Umar, Dua Pusaka Nabi Saw. Al-Qur’an Dan Ahlulbait: Kajian Islam Autentik Pasca Kenabian (Ilya, 2010)
Al-Ḥanbalī, Abū Al-‘Abbās Taqiyy Al-Dīn Ibn Taymiyyah Al-Dimashqī, Minhāj Al-Sunnah Al-Nabawiyyah Fī Naqḍ Kalām Al-Shī‘ah Al-Qadariyyah, ed. by Muḥammad Rashād Sālim (Jāmi‘at Al-Imām Muḥammad Ibn Sa‘ūd Al-Islāmiyyah, 1986), VII
Al-Haytamī, Aḥmad Ibn Aḥmad Ibn Muḥammad Ibn ‘Alī Ibn Ḥajar, Al-Ṣawā‘iq Al-Muḥarraqah ‘Alā Ahl Al-Rafḍ Wa Al-Ḍalāl Wa Al-Zindiqah (Mu’assasat Al-Risālah, 1997), II
Al-Ḥillī, Abū Al-Qāsim Najm Al-Dīn Ja‘fār Ibn Al-Ḥasan, Al-Mukhtaṣar Al-Nāfi‘ Fī Fiqh Al-Imāmiyyah, Cetakan Ketiga (Mu’assat Al-Bi’thah, 1410)
Al-Jamā‘īl, Muwaffiq Al-Dīn ‘Abdullah Ibn Aḥmad Ibn Quddāmah, Rawḍat Al-Nāẓir Wa Junnat Al-Manāẓir Fī Uṣūl Al-Fiqh ‘Alā Madhhab Al-Imām Aḥmad Ibn Ḥanbal, 2nd edn (Mu’assasat Al-Rayyān Li Al-Ṭibā‘ah Wa Al-Nashr Wa Al-Tawzī’, 2002)
Al-Khurrāsānī, Ibrāhīm al-Juwaynī, Farā’id al-Simṭayn Fī Faḍā’il al-Murtaḍā Wa al-Butūl Wa al-Sabṭayn Wa al-A’immah Min Dhurriyyatihim ‘Alayhim al-Salām, ed. by Muḥammad Bāqir Al-Maḥmūdī (Dār al-Ḥabīb, 1428), II
Al-Kulaynī, Muhammad ibn Ya‘qūb, Uṣūl Al-Kāfī, Jilid 1, Cetakan Ketiga (Dār al-Kutub al-Islāmiyyah, 1388)
Al-Majlisī, Muḥammad Bāqir, Bihar Al-Anwar (Mu’assasat al-Wafā’, 1983), II
Al-Naysabūrī, Abū Al-Ḥusayn Muslim ibn Al-Hajjāj Al-Qushayrī, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim, Jilid 7 (Bayt Al-Afkār Al-Dawliyyah, 1998)
Al-Qārī, ‘Alī Ibn Ṣūlṭān Muḥammad Nūr Al-Dīn Al-Mulā Al-Hirawī, Mirqāt Al-Mafātīḥ Sharḥ Mishkāt Al-Maṣābīḥ (Dār Al-Fikr, 2002), IX
Al-Qurashī, Abū al-Fidā’ Ismā‘īl ibn ‘Umar ibn Kathīr, Tafsīr Al-Qur’ān al-‘Aẓīm, ed. by Muḥammad Ḥusayn Syams Al-Dīn (Dār al-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyyah, 2004), VII
Al-Qurṭubī, Aḥmad ibn ‘Umar ibn Ibrāhīm, Al-Mufhim Limā Ashkala Min Kitāb Talkhīṣ Muslim (Dār Ibn Kathīr, 1996), XX
Al-Rāzī, Abū Muḥammad ‘Abd al-Rahmān ibn Muḥammad ibn Abī Ḥātim, Al-Jarḥ Wa Al-Ta‘dīl (Dār Iḥyā’ Al-Turāth Al-‘Arabī, 1952)
Al-Sakhāwī, Syams al-Dīn Muḥammad ibn ’Abd al-Raḥmān, Al-Ajwibah al-Marḍiyyah Fīmā Su’ila al-Sakhāwī ‘Anhu Min al-Aḥādīth al-Nabawiyyah, Jilid 2, Cetakan Pertama (Daar Al-Rayah Li Al-Nasyr wa Al-Tawzi’, 1418)
Al-Samhūdī, ‘Alī ibn ‘Abdullah al-Ḥasanī, Jawāhir Al-‘Iqdayn Fī Faḍl al-Sharafayn Sharaf al-‘Ilm al-Jalī Wa al-Nasab al-‘Alī (Wizārat al-Awqāf, 1948)
Al-Sijistānī, Muḥammad Ibn Ḥibbān Ibn Aḥmad Ibn Ḥibbān, Al-Majrūḥīn Min Al-Muḥaddithīn (Dār Al-Ṣamī‘ī, 2000)
Al-Ṭabarī, Abū Ja‘far Muḥammad Ibn Jarīr, Tārīkh Al-Rusul Wa Al-Muluk, ed. by Muḥammad Abū Al-Faḍl Ibrāhīm (Dār Al-Ma‘ārif, 1967)
Al-Ṭabrānī, Sulaymān Ibn Aḥmad Ibn Ayyūb Ibn Muṭīr Al-Khummī Al-Shāmī, Al-Mu‘jam Al-Ṣaghīr, ed. by Muḥammad Shakūr Maḥmūd Al-Ḥāh Amrīr (Dār ‘Ammār, 1985), I
Al-Ṭabrisī, Abū Mansūr Aḥmad Ibn ‘Alī Ibn Abī Ṭālib, Al-Ihtijaj ’Alā Ahl Al-Lajāj (Maṭābi’ Al-Nu’mān, 1966), II
Al-Tamīmī, Muḥammad ibn Ḥibbān ibn Aḥmad ibn Ḥibbān, Al-Thiqāt, Jilid 8 (Dairah Al-Ma’arif Al-Uthmaniyyah, 1973)
Al-Tirmidhī, Abū ‘Īsā Muḥammad ibn ‘Īsā, Sunan Al-Tirmidhī, ed. by Bashār ‘Awwād Ma‘rūf (Dār al-Gharb al-Islāmī, 1996)
Al-‘Uqaylī, Abū Ja‘far Muḥammad Ibn ‘Amr Ibn Mūsā Ibn Ḥammād, Kitāb Al-Ḍu‘Afā’ Al-Kabīr (Dār Al-Kutub Al-‘Ilmiyyah, 1984)
Azizan, Ahmad Salahuddin M., Zulhilmi Mohamed Nor, and Muhammad Akmalludin Mohd Hamdan, ‘Metodologi Kritikan Sanad Riwayat Sirah: Satu Kajian Terhadap Akram Ḍiyā’ Al-ʿumarī Dalam Karyanya Al-Sīrah Al- Nabawiyyah Al-Ṣaḥīḥah’, Journal Of Hadith Studies, 2024, pp. 81–89, doi:10.33102/johs.v9i1.289
Babgure, Hesam, ‘The Concept of Leadership in Sunni and Shia Perspectives’, Ampera: A Research Journal on Politics and Islamic Civilization, 4.01 (2023), pp. 1–10, doi:10.19109/ampera.v4i01.22225
Baḥshal, Aslam Ibn Sahl Ibn Al-Razāz Al-Wāsiṭī, Tārīkh Wāsiṭ (‘Ālam Al-Kutub, 1986)
Bāz, ‘Abd al-‘Azīz Ibn Bāz ‘Abdullah Ibn, Majmū‘ Fatāwā Wa Maqālāt Mutanawwi‘ah, ed. by Muḥammad ibn Sa’d Al-Shuway‘ir (Dār al-Qāsim Li al-Nashr, 1420), III
Bloor, Michael, and Fiona Wood, Keyword in Qualitative Methods (SAGE Publication, 2006)
Hamid, Rahmat, Husni Idrus, and Hasaruddin Hasaruddin, ‘Sunni and Shia: An Approach From Islamic Thought’, Jurnal Al-Dustur, 6.1 (2023), pp. 50–71, doi:10.30863/aldustur.v6i1.3777
Hartono, Heki, ‘Menyoal Hadis Tsaqalain Di Indonesia: Tentang Berpegang Teguh Pada Dua Peninggalan Rasulullah’, Islami[Dot]Co, 2020 [accessed 1 July 2024]
———, ‘Relasi Kuasa Dalam Wacana Berpegang Teguh Kepada Dua Pusaka Peninggalan Rasulullah (Hadis Tsaqalain) Di Indonesia’, UNIVERSUM : Jurnal KeIslaman Dan Kebudayaan, Vol 13, No 1 (2019), 2019
Hidayah, Nurul, Agneis Novirieka Harahap, Ibnopita Ibnopita, Ubed Muhtarom, and Tobroni Tobroni, ‘Islamic Leadership Concepts and Theories’, FIKROTUNA: Jurnal Pendidikan Dan Manajemen Islam, 16.02 (2023), pp. 306–22, doi:10.32806/jf.v16i02.5708
Hidayat, Asep Achmad, Gelar Taufiq Kusumawardhana, Ading Kusdiana, Usman Supendi, Wawan Hernawan, and Chye Retty Isnendes, ‘Ahlul Bait’s First Arrival in Indonesia and The Exploration of Islamic History in Southeast Asia’, Al-Tsaqafa : Jurnal Ilmiah Peradaban Islam, 20.2 (2023), pp. 172–93, doi:10.15575/al-tsaqafa.v20i2.29802
Irfanullah, Gumilar, Dewi Anggraeni, and Ina Agustina, ‘Ahlul Bait Dalam Puisi-Puisi Penyair Keturunan Bani Umayyah: Studi Historis dan Kritik Sastra Atas Karya Abu Adiy al-Umawi, Marwan as-Saruji dan Al-Abiwardi’, Jurnal Tamaddun, 11.2 (2023), doi:10.24235/tamaddun.v11i2.15218
Kamaluddin, Ahmad, ‘Naqd As-Sanad : Metodologi Validasi Hadits Shahih’, MUSHAF JOURNAL: Jurnal Ilmu Al Quran Dan Hadis, 3.2 (2023), pp. 229–39, doi:10.54443/mushaf.v3i2.136
Khair, Nurul, ‘Peristiwa Ghadir Khum Dalam Pandangan Teolog Muslim’, Aqlania, 11.2 (2020), p. 221, doi:10.32678/aqlania.v11i2.2811
Lestari, Lenni, ‘Epistemologi Hadis Perspektif Syi‘ah’, Al-Bukhari : Jurnal Ilmu Hadis, 2.1 (2019), pp. 39–52, doi:10.32505/al-bukhari.v2i1.1130
Manan, Abdul, and Jovial Pally Taran, ‘The Sunni-Shia Conflict in the History of Islam: An Analytical Descriptive Study’, Palita: Journal of Social Religion Research, 5.2 (2020), pp. 165–82, doi:10.24256/pal.v5i2.1327
Masykuri, Fita Mustafida, Fahruddin Andriansyah, and Dian Mohammad Hakim, ‘Sunni-Shia Conflict Resolution Strategy And Its Impact On Harmonizing The Society: Evidence From Sampang, Madura’, Al-Qanatir: International Journal of Islamic Studies, 33.3 (2024), pp. 423–30
Mattori, Muhammad, ‘Sikap Syiah Terhadap Sunnah/Hadis Nabi SAW’, Tahdis: Jurnal Kajian Ilmu Al-Hadis, 13.1 (2022), pp. 54–64, doi:10.24252/tahdis.v13i1.26257
Miles, Matthew B., and A. Michael Huberman, Qualitative Data Analysis, Second Edition (SAGE Publication, 1994)
Muhid, Moh Imron, and Andris Nurita, ‘Ke-’adalah-an Aisyah Perspektif Syiah dan Implikasinya Terhadap Hadis Nabi’, Al-Bukhari : Jurnal Ilmu Hadis, 6.1 (2023), pp. 66–91, doi:10.32505/al-bukhari.v6i1.5309
Muzakky, Althaf Husein, and Agung Syaikhul Mukarrom, ‘Studi Hadis Menghormati Ahlulbait: Dari Pemahaman Tekstualis Sampai Kontekstualis’, Riwayah: Jurnal Studi Hadis, 7.1 (2021), pp. 67–88, doi:10.21043/riwayah.v7i1.8999
Nasrullah, Sanip, ‘Authority of History and Sharah Hadith Thaqalayn (Sunnah Itrah)’, Journal of Hadith Studies, 3.1 (2020), pp. 34–43, doi:10.32506/johs.v3i1.627
Noor, Dzulkifli, ‘Kafa`ah Dalam Pandangan Ahlul Bait’, Emanasi : Jurnal Ilmu Keislaman dan Sosial, 6.1 (2023), pp. 49–61
Nugroho, Kharis, ‘Al-Kulaini’s Canonization of Al-Kafi’, Tasfiyah: Jurnal Pemikiran Islam, 6.1 (2022), pp. 115–42, doi:https://doi.org/10.21111/tasfiyah.v6i1.7620
Posha, Beti Yanuri, ‘Penggunaan Hadis Ghadir Khum Sebagai Sumber Sejarah’, Jurnal SAMBAS (Studi Agama, Masyarakat, Budaya, Adat, Sejarah): Journal of Religious, Community, Culture, Costume, History Studies), 6.1 (2023), pp. 33–44, doi:10.37567/sambas.v6i1.1905
Rahman, Bobbi Aidi, ‘The Event of Ghadir Khum: ‘Ali Bin Abi Thalib’s Leadership in Sunni and Shi’a Perspectives’, El-Afkar: Jurnal Pemikiran Keislaman Dan Tafsir Hadis, 13.1 (2024), pp. 44–60, doi:10.29300/jpkth.v13i1.3452
Rifqi, Muhammad Hasan, and Ahmad Masyhur, ‘The Legality of the Leadership of Abu Bakr, Umar, and Usman: The Ismaili and Zaidiyah Shia Perspectives’, Scientia, 2.1 (2023), pp. 387–92, doi:10.51773/sssh.v2i1.181
Rizaka, Maghza, and Muhammad Wahid Hasyim, ‘A Takhrīj Study of The Hadith Al-Thaqalayn in Sunan Al-Tirmidhī’, Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, 5.4 (2024), pp. 1723–36, doi:10.59141/jist.v5i4.1030
Rizaka, Maghza, Muhid Muhid, Andris Nurita, and Arfedin Hamas Khoshyatulloh, ‘Interpretasi Imam Al-Kulaynī Terhadap Hadis Al-Thaqalayni Dalam Pendekatan Sosio-Historis’, TAJDID: Jurnal Ilmu Ushuluddin, 22.2 (2023), pp. 359–85, doi:10.30631/tjd.v22i2.385
Rizaka, Maghza, Ahmad Fauzan Zahri, Nadia Maulida Mahbubiati, Achmadana Syachrizal M. F, and Aan Darwati, ‘Kajian Asbāb Al-Wurūd Terhadap Hadis Al-Thaqalayn’, KACA (Karunia Cahaya Allah): Jurnal Dialogis Ilmu Ushuluddin, 14.1 (2024), pp. 107–29, doi:10.36781/kaca.v14i1.587
Tahiiev, Akif, ‘Female Leadership in Shia Islam: Women on the Way from Mujtahid to Marja’’, Societies, 14.1 (2024), p. 2, doi:10.3390/soc14010002
Wensinck, Arnold John, Al-Mu`jam Al-Mufahras Li Alfāẓ Al-Ḥadith Al-Nabawī, Jilid 1 (Maktabah Brail, 1936)
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.22373/jim.v21i2.24745
Copyright (c) 2024 Maghza Rizaka, Ferdy Pratama, Imam Ghazali Said
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
INDEXED BY:
_(1).png)
1.png)
1.png)
.png)
1.png)
1.png)
1.png)
_(1).png)
EDITORIAL OFFICE:
Syeikh Abdur Rauf Street, Faculty of Islamic Theology and Philosophy Building, Universitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry Banda Aceh, Banda Aceh, Postal Code 23111 Indonesia
Email: Jurnalmuashirah@ar-raniry.ac.id
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.