Correction and Retraction

https://jurnal.ar-raniry.ac.id/index.php/lantanida/correction_and_retractionhttps://jurnal.ar-raniry.ac.id/index.php/lantanida/correction_and_retractionLantanida Journal maintains the integrity of the academic record through transparent processes for correcting errors and retracting compromised publications. In alignment with Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) guidelines, the journal ensures that post-publication amendments preserve historical context while clearly indicating necessary revisions.
 
1. Corrections (Errata and Corrigenda)
When errors are identified post-publication that do not invalidate the scientific validity or core findings of a study, Lantanida Journal issues a formal correction notice.
 
1.1 Categories of Corrections
Erratum: Issued to correct significant errors introduced by the publisher during editing, formatting, or production (e.g., misprinted tables, missing equations, or layout errors that impair readability).
 
Corrigendum: Issued when authors identify inadvertent errors post-publication (e.g., minor analytical discrepancies, mislabeled figures, chemical structure misprints, or omitted funding/acknowledgment details).
 
1.2 Publication Standards for Corrections
A formal Correction Notice is published in the next available issue, assigned a DOI, and linked to the original manuscript.
 
The original online version of the article remains accessible on the Open Journal Systems (OJS) platform, updated with a note referencing the correction date and a direct link to the published notice.
 
2. Expressions of Concern
An Expression of Concern is a formal notice published by the Editor-in-Chief to alert readers to potential issues when an article’s integrity is under review.
 
2.1 Criteria for Issuance
An ongoing investigation into alleged research misconduct (e.g., data manipulation, image manipulation, uncredited plagiarism) yields inconclusive results or requires extended institutional inquiries.
 
There is evidence of serious methodological errors or data reliability issues, but definitive proof for retraction has not yet been established.
 
2.2 Status and Duration
An Expression of Concern is linked directly to the original article page on OJS.
 
Upon completion of a full inquiry, the Expression of Concern is either resolved (and replaced by a Correction or Retraction) or maintained if institutional findings remain ambiguous.
 
3. Article Retractions
Retraction is reserved for published manuscripts where findings are so severely compromised that the conclusions can no longer be trusted, or where serious ethical breaches have occurred.
 
3.1 Grounds for Retraction
In accordance with COPE guidelines, a manuscript will be retracted if:
 
Ethical Misconduct: Unambiguous evidence of data fabrication, data falsification, image manipulation, or severe uncredited plagiarism is established.
 
Redundant Publication: The work has been published elsewhere without proper cross-referencing, attribution, or editorial permission.
 
Unresolvable Error: Major, honest scientific errors (e.g., flawed calculations, unreproducible chemical syntheses, unviable experimental setups) render the findings completely invalid.
 
Unethical Research: The research violated established ethical standards or lacked required institutional review board (IRB) approval.
 
3.2 Retraction Mechanics and Transparency
Permanent Record: To maintain the historical continuity of the scientific literature, the original article is never deleted or removed from the journal repository.
 
Watermarking: The original PDF is modified with a prominent, immutable watermark reading "RETRACTED" across every page.
 
Formal Retraction Notice: A separate Retraction Notice is published under the name of the Editor-in-Chief, author(s), or institution. It details the precise reasons for retraction, identifies who initiated the action, and contains a direct link to the watermarked article.