Post-Publication Discussion

Lantanida Journal recognizes that peer-reviewed literature is an ongoing scientific dialogue. The journal provides structured mechanisms for academic debate, correction of errors, and transparent post-publication peer review to protect the integrity of published chemistry and chemistry education research.
 
1. Post-Publication Scientific Dialogue
Lantanida Journal encourages robust academic debate regarding published manuscripts. Readers, researchers, and subject-matter experts may initiate post-publication discussions through formal channels:
 
1.1 Letters to the Editor / Commentary Submissions
Format & Scope: Readers may submit a Letter to the Editor or Matters Arising comment addressing specific methodology, data interpretations, or theoretical claims in a published paper.
 
Editorial Review: The handling editorial board reviews the submission for scientific validity, relevance, and constructive, professional tone. Personal attacks or non-academic critiques are rejected.
 
Right of Reply: If accepted, the original authors of the paper are provided the critique and invited to submit a formal Author Response.
 
Paired Publication: The commentary and the authors' response are published together in a subsequent issue and directly linked to the original article on the journal’s OJS platform.
 
1.2 PubPeer and External Post-Publication Peer Review
The editorial team monitors external scientific integrity platforms (e.g., PubPeer) for community feedback or flagged anomalies (such as image duplication or data errors in spectra).
 
Valid concerns raised externally trigger the journal's internal investigation protocol, with authors requested to provide original raw datasets.
 
2. Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions
When post-publication evaluations reveal inaccuracies, errors, or ethical breaches, Lantanida Journal issues appropriate amendments to ensure the scientific record remains accurate and transparent.
 
2.1 Corrections (Errata and Corrigenda)
Erratum: Issued to correct significant editorial or formatting errors introduced by the publisher during production that affect paper clarity or accuracy.
 
Corrigendum: Issued when authors identify inadvertent errors post-publication (e.g., mislabeled tables, minor chemical structure misprints, missed acknowledgments) that do not undermine the overall conclusions of the research.
 
Implementation: The original online PDF remains accessible, accompanied by an updated version clearly indicating the change date, alongside a standalone published correction notice.
 
2.2 Expressions of Concern
The Editor-in-Chief may issue an Expression of Concern if:
 
An investigation into alleged research misconduct or data manipulation is ongoing, but a conclusive outcome has not yet been reached.
 
There is evidence that an inquiry is unbiased or inconclusive, yet serious doubts remain regarding the validity of the research findings.
 
2.3 Retractions
An article is retracted following COPE guidelines if post-publication inquiry reveals severe scientific flaws or ethical violations:
 
Triggers: Proven data fabrication/falsification, pervasive uncredited plagiarism, redundant/duplicate publication, or fundamental unresolvable methodological errors.
 
Retraction Mechanics:
 
The original PDF is retained on the platform to maintain the historical record, but it is clearly watermarked "RETRACTED" on every page.
 
A formal Retraction Notice is published, explaining the grounds for retraction and citing the party requesting it (authors, editors, or institutions).
 
The retraction notice is permanently linked to the original article page and indexed across scientific databases.