Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement

DAYAH: Journal of Islamic Education, published by the Master's Program in Islamic Education, Graduate School, Universitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry, Banda Aceh, is committed to upholding the integrity, credibility, transparency, and independence of scholarly publishing.

The journal maintains ethical standards throughout manuscript submission, editorial screening, peer review, publication, and post-publication assessment. These standards apply to authors, editors, reviewers, editorial staff, and the publisher. The journal's editorial practices are guided by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), particularly its Core Practices and Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing.

Contents

1. Editorial Independence and Publication Decisions

The Editor-in-Chief is responsible for the final decision on whether a submitted manuscript is accepted, revised, or rejected. Editorial decisions are based on academic merit, originality, methodological rigor, relevance to Islamic education, quality of evidence, ethical compliance, and the contribution of the manuscript to scholarly knowledge.

The journal evaluates manuscripts without discrimination based on nationality, gender, ethnicity, religious affiliation, institutional affiliation, disability, political beliefs, or other characteristics unrelated to scholarly quality.

Editorial decisions are independent of commercial interests and financial considerations. Payment of article processing charges does not influence peer review or guarantee publication. Manuscripts authored by editors, editorial board members, or individuals affiliated with the publisher are subject to independent editorial handling and the same scholarly standards as other submissions.

2. Duties and Responsibilities of Editors

Editors are responsible for maintaining an impartial, confidential, transparent, and academically sound evaluation process.

  • Assess manuscript suitability, originality, scholarly significance, and compliance with journal policies.
  • Select qualified reviewers and ensure that the double-blind review process is properly maintained.
  • Evaluate reviewer recommendations critically and issue reasoned editorial decisions.
  • Protect confidential manuscripts, reviewer identities, correspondence, and unpublished research materials.
  • Disclose conflicts of interest and withdraw from editorial decisions when impartiality cannot be assured.
  • Avoid using unpublished data, interpretations, or ideas for personal research without explicit authorization.
  • Investigate credible allegations of research or publication misconduct.
  • Facilitate corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions when necessary to protect the scholarly record.
  • Ensure that authors have a fair opportunity to respond to substantive concerns about their work.

3. Duties and Responsibilities of Peer Reviewers

DAYAH implements a double-blind peer review process to promote impartiality and academic independence. Reviewers must provide objective, constructive, evidence-based assessments of manuscripts assigned to them.

  • Accept review invitations only when they have relevant expertise and adequate time to complete the assessment.
  • Assess originality, literature engagement, conceptual framework, research design, evidence, analysis, and conclusions.
  • Provide substantive and respectful recommendations supported by clear academic reasoning.
  • Notify the editor of potential plagiarism, substantial overlap, citation manipulation, or other ethical concerns.
  • Maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts and editorial correspondence.
  • Decline review assignments involving financial, institutional, personal, or academic conflicts of interest.
  • Refrain from using unpublished information for personal or professional advantage.
  • Avoid coercive citation requests intended to inflate personal or journal citation metrics.

Reviewers must not distribute manuscripts to unauthorized individuals or upload confidential manuscript materials to external AI services without authorization and appropriate confidentiality safeguards.

4. Duties and Responsibilities of Authors

Authors are accountable for the originality, reliability, accuracy, and ethical integrity of their submissions.

  • Submit original research that has not been published or submitted simultaneously elsewhere.
  • Report research objectives, methods, findings, and interpretations accurately.
  • Acknowledge the intellectual contributions of other scholars through appropriate citations.
  • Ensure that all reported data, quotations, documents, and research materials are authentic.
  • Disclose research funding, conflicts of interest, and relevant forms of external assistance.
  • Obtain required permissions for copyrighted materials and identifiable research information.
  • Respond to editorial inquiries and reviewer comments professionally and transparently.
  • Promptly inform the journal of significant errors identified before or after publication.

5. Authorship, Contributorship, and Author Disputes

Authorship must reflect genuine scholarly contributions to a manuscript. Authors should have contributed substantially to the research conception or design, data collection or interpretation, analysis, or critical development of the manuscript, and must approve the final version and accept accountability for their contributions.

All eligible contributors must be appropriately recognized. Gift authorship, guest authorship, honorary authorship, and deliberate exclusion of qualifying contributors are unacceptable. Technical assistance, administrative support, language editing, and other contributions that do not qualify for authorship should be acknowledged with the contributor's permission.

The corresponding author is responsible for coordinating approval of the submitted and final manuscripts, maintaining communication with the editorial office, and ensuring that all authors agree to the authorship order and contribution statements.

Requests to add, remove, or rearrange authors after submission must include an explanation and the agreement of the affected authors. Where disputes remain unresolved, the journal may request assessment by the relevant institutions before proceeding with publication.

6. Originality, Plagiarism, and Duplicate Publication

The journal prohibits plagiarism, unattributed paraphrasing, misappropriation of research ideas, substantial undisclosed text reuse, and redundant publication. All sources, including previously published work by the authors, must be properly cited.

Manuscripts are screened for textual similarity using Turnitin. Similarity results are assessed in context, taking into account legitimate quotations, references, conventional methodological wording, and the extent and nature of overlapping material. A similarity report is a screening instrument and does not independently establish plagiarism.

Manuscripts containing substantial unattributed overlap may be rejected. Authors may be requested to clarify or correct minor citation or attribution problems. Serious or deliberate plagiarism is treated as a publication ethics violation.

Simultaneous submission to another journal is prohibited. Substantial overlap with a previously published article must be disclosed to the editorial office. Related work may be considered only where the new manuscript offers a genuinely distinct and adequately documented scholarly contribution.

7. Research Integrity, Data Management, and Reproducibility

Authors must accurately present the methods, evidence, data, and findings supporting their conclusions. Fabrication, falsification, misleading selective reporting, inappropriate manipulation of figures, and deliberate misrepresentation of research procedures are prohibited.

Methods should be described with sufficient detail to permit critical scholarly assessment and, where appropriate, replication or verification. Quantitative studies should report relevant sampling procedures, instruments, analytical techniques, and statistical results. Qualitative studies should explain participant selection, data collection, analytical procedures, and the basis for interpreting research evidence.

Authors should retain relevant research records and supporting materials in accordance with institutional requirements and applicable law. Where access to data is restricted by confidentiality, consent, or legal obligations, these restrictions should be explained.

The journal may request clarification or supporting materials where questions arise about the integrity or reliability of a submission. Requests for access must respect participant rights, intellectual property, and data protection obligations.

8. Ethical Oversight and Protection of Research Participants

Research involving human participants must respect autonomy, dignity, safety, privacy, and voluntary participation. Researchers must obtain informed consent where required and explain the nature and purpose of participation in a manner appropriate to the research context.

Educational research involving schoolchildren, students, teachers, or vulnerable populations requires particular attention to power relationships, confidentiality, voluntary participation, and potential risks. Permission from a school or institution does not, by itself, replace individual consent or other applicable safeguards.

Where institutional ethics review or approval is required, authors must obtain it and provide relevant information in the manuscript. Where formal approval is not required, authors should explain the ethical procedures adopted.

Personally identifiable information, photographs, interview quotations, and sensitive records must not be disclosed without an appropriate ethical basis and the necessary consent or authorization.

9. Conflicts of Interest and Funding Disclosure

Authors, editors, and reviewers must disclose relationships or interests that could influence, or reasonably appear to influence, the conduct, presentation, evaluation, or publication of research.

Potential competing interests include financial support, employment, institutional relationships, personal connections, research collaborations, academic competition, and relevant intellectual or ideological commitments.

Authors must disclose research funding and describe any involvement of sponsors in study design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, manuscript preparation, or publication decisions. Where no competing interests exist, authors should provide a declaration to that effect.

Editors and reviewers who cannot provide an impartial evaluation must withdraw from the relevant editorial assignment. Disclosed interests are evaluated by the journal, and appropriate safeguards are applied when necessary.

10. Generative Artificial Intelligence Policy

Generative AI and AI-assisted technologies may be used for appropriate support activities, including language improvement, grammar checking, and technical editing, provided that their use does not undermine research originality, accuracy, confidentiality, or accountability.

Authors must disclose substantive AI-assisted contributions to manuscript preparation, data processing, analysis, translation, or visual material generation. Disclosures should identify the tool and describe its purpose and role. AI systems cannot be listed as authors.

Authors remain fully accountable for all manuscript content. They must verify AI-assisted statements, interpretations, quotations, citations, and references. Fabricated data, invented interviews, fictitious references, and misleading representations of AI-generated material as authentic research evidence are prohibited.

Reviewers and editors must not upload confidential submissions to external AI systems without appropriate authorization and safeguards. Editorial decisions remain the responsibility of qualified human editors.

11. Allegations of Research and Publication Misconduct

The journal considers credible concerns about misconduct arising before or after publication. Such concerns may involve authors, editors, reviewers, third-party services, or other participants in scholarly publishing.

Allegations may include plagiarism, data fabrication or falsification, unethical treatment of participants, fraudulent authorship, citation manipulation, undisclosed redundant publication, compromised peer review, or deliberate misrepresentation of research evidence.

The handling process includes:

  1. Initial assessment: The editor determines whether the concern is sufficiently specific and credible to warrant examination.
  2. Evidence review: Relevant editorial records, manuscript materials, and supporting information are evaluated confidentially.
  3. Author response: Individuals concerned are given an appropriate opportunity to respond and provide explanations or evidence.
  4. Independent consideration: Editors with conflicts of interest withdraw from the assessment. Where necessary, the journal seeks advice from independent experts or the relevant institutions.
  5. Editorial action: Depending on the findings, the journal may request revision, reject a manuscript, publish a correction or expression of concern, retract an article, or refer the matter for institutional investigation.

Complaints are assessed fairly and proportionately. Allegations are not regarded as established misconduct without an appropriate examination. Confidentiality is maintained as far as compatible with a fair investigation.

12. Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions

DAYAH maintains the integrity and transparency of the published record by addressing significant errors and ethical concerns in accordance with their effect on the reliability of scholarly content.

Corrections

Corrections address substantive errors that require public amendment or clarification but do not invalidate the central findings or conclusions of an article.

Expressions of Concern

An expression of concern may be published when significant questions concerning an article's integrity remain unresolved or an appropriate investigation is ongoing.

Retractions

Retraction may be necessary when findings are unreliable because of major errors or misconduct, or when serious plagiarism, redundant publication, or ethical violations undermine the validity of the published work.

Retraction is intended to correct the scholarly record rather than punish authors. Notices must identify the affected article, explain the reason for editorial action, and remain publicly accessible and linked to the original publication.

Retracted articles ordinarily remain accessible with a clear retraction designation. Removal of published content is reserved for exceptional circumstances involving serious legal, privacy, or safety concerns.

13. Post-Publication Discussion

DAYAH welcomes responsible scholarly discussion of published articles, including substantive questions about methodology, research evidence, interpretation, and academic conclusions.

Readers and researchers may submit well-supported comments, scholarly responses, or concerns to the editorial office. Contributions must be relevant, evidence-based, and expressed in professional academic language.

The editorial team assesses post-publication submissions and determines the appropriate response. Where necessary, the journal may invite the original authors to respond or publish a clarification, scholarly commentary, correction, or other suitable notice.

14. Complaints and Appeals

Authors may appeal editorial decisions where they believe that a material factual error, procedural irregularity, or significant misunderstanding has affected the evaluation of their manuscript.

Appeals must be submitted in writing, identify the relevant manuscript and decision, and explain the grounds for reconsideration. Mere disagreement with an unfavorable editorial decision does not, by itself, establish a valid appeal.

Complaints concerning editorial conduct, peer review, confidentiality, conflicts of interest, or publication ethics may also be submitted to the editorial office. Complaints involving an editor are assessed without that editor's participation.

The journal evaluates complaints and appeals impartially and may seek an independent opinion where appropriate. Decisions and outcomes are communicated to the relevant parties while respecting confidentiality.

15. Publisher Responsibilities, Copyright, and Transparency

The publishing institution supports the journal's editorial independence and the implementation of ethical publication practices. The publisher and editorial team cooperate in addressing concerns about research integrity, intellectual property, confidentiality, and the accuracy of published content.

Authors retain copyright and grant the journal the right of first publication. Articles are published under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License (CC BY-SA 4.0), which permits sharing and adaptation with appropriate attribution and compliance with the ShareAlike condition.

Publication fees, when applicable, are disclosed separately through the journal's Article Processing Charges policy. Such fees do not guarantee acceptance or confer preferential editorial treatment.

The journal's publication ethics policy operates alongside its author guidelines, peer review process, plagiarism policy, copyright policy, and other editorial regulations.

16. Publication Ethics Inquiries

Questions about publication ethics, allegations of misconduct, appeals, corrections, and post-publication concerns may be addressed to the editorial office.

DAYAH: Journal of Islamic Education

Master's Program in Islamic Education, Graduate School, Universitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry, Banda Aceh, Indonesia.

Email: jie@ar-raniry.ac.id

Contact: Journal Contact Information

Publication Ethics Framework

This policy follows the ethical principles articulated by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), including guidance on ethical oversight, authorship, conflicts of interest, complaints and appeals, research misconduct, peer review, and the maintenance of the scholarly record.