Author Guideline

AUTHOR GUIDELINES & MANUSCRIPT TEMPLATE

Title Of The Manuscript      

(Cambria, 14 PT, Capital Each Word, Align Left, 1.0 Spacing)

The title should accurately, concisely, and comprehensively represent the content of the manuscript while reflecting its originality, scope, and scientific contribution. As the first element encountered by editors, reviewers, indexing services, and readers, the title plays a crucial role in attracting attention, enhancing discoverability, and increasing the visibility of the published work. Authors are encouraged to formulate a title that clearly communicates the primary research topic, key concepts or variables, and, where appropriate, the study context or target population. The title should normally consist of 12–20 words and should not exceed 25 words. It should be written in Title Case, using clear and internationally recognized academic terminology, and should avoid unexplained abbreviations, mathematical expressions, symbols, commercial names, rhetorical phrases, and subjective or promotional language such as novel, innovative, effective, or best, unless such claims are directly supported by the research findings. Authors should also ensure that the terminology used in the title is consistent with the abstract, keywords, and the main body of the manuscript to improve indexing, retrieval, and citation in international databases.

 

ABSTRACT

(Cambria, 11 PT, Capital Each Word, Justified, 1.0 Spacing)

Abstract should provide a concise, accurate, and self-contained summary of the entire manuscript, enabling readers, editors, reviewers, and indexing services to understand the purpose, methodology, principal findings, and significance of the study without referring to the full text. The abstract should be written as one continuous paragraph consisting of 200–250 words and should briefly describe the research background, clearly identify the research gap or unresolved issue that motivated the study, state the research objectives, summarize the research design, participants or data sources, data collection procedures, and analytical methods, present only the principal findings that directly address the research objectives, and conclude with the main theoretical, practical, or policy implications of the study. The abstract should emphasize the originality and contribution of the research while maintaining objectivity and avoiding unsupported claims or promotional language. Citations, references, footnotes, tables, figures, equations, excessive statistical details, and undefined abbreviations should not be included. Authors should ensure that the abstract is consistent with the main manuscript and accurately reflects the study without introducing information that is not discussed in the full text. Clear, concise, and grammatically accurate academic English should be used throughout, allowing the abstract to function as an independent representation of the manuscript and to maximize its visibility and discoverability in international indexing databases.

Keyword:  Provide tree to seven keywords that accurately represent the scientific content of the manuscript.

 

INTRODUCTION

(Cambria, 12 PT, Capital Each Word, Justified, 1.15 Spacing)

The Introduction serves as the intellectual foundation of the manuscript and should provide readers with a clear understanding of the research context, the significance of the problem, the current state of knowledge, and the scientific rationale underlying the study. Rather than merely introducing the research topic, this section should construct a logical and persuasive academic argument demonstrating why the study is necessary and how it contributes to the advancement of knowledge within the discipline. Authors are encouraged to guide readers progressively from the broader context of the research toward the specific objectives of the study through a coherent sequence of well-developed paragraphs supported by current and credible scholarly literature.

The Introduction should begin by presenting the broader background of the research topic and explaining its academic, practical, technological, social, educational, environmental, economic, or policy significance, depending on the scope of the study. The opening discussion should be supported by recent empirical evidence, authoritative reports, or internationally recognized statistical data rather than general statements or dictionary definitions. Authors should clearly demonstrate the importance of the research problem and explain why the issue deserves scholarly attention in both international and local contexts.

Following the general background, authors should provide a critical synthesis of previous studies relevant to the research topic. The purpose of this discussion is not merely to summarize existing literature but to evaluate, compare, and integrate previous findings while identifying patterns, inconsistencies, methodological limitations, theoretical debates, or unresolved issues within the current body of knowledge. The literature should primarily consist of recent peer-reviewed journal articles indexed in internationally recognized databases such as Scopus or Web of Science. Approximately 70–80% of cited references are expected to have been published within the last five to ten years, except for seminal theories or classical works that remain fundamental to the discipline. Authors are encouraged to organize the discussion thematically or conceptually rather than chronologically to strengthen the coherence of the scholarly argument.

Based on the critical review of previous studies, authors should explicitly identify the research gap that justifies the present investigation. The research gap may arise from contradictory findings, methodological weaknesses, insufficient theoretical explanations, underrepresented populations, limited geographical contexts, emerging technologies, changes in educational or governmental policies, or practical challenges that have not yet been adequately addressed. Rather than simply stating that "few studies have examined this topic," authors should clearly explain what specific aspects remain unknown, insufficiently explored, or theoretically unresolved and why these limitations warrant further investigation.

The Introduction should then describe the novelty and originality of the study by explaining how the present research differs from and extends previous investigations. Authors should demonstrate whether the study introduces a new theoretical perspective, proposes an innovative methodological approach, applies an existing framework within a different context, develops a new instrument or intervention, integrates multiple disciplines, or provides new empirical evidence that advances current understanding. Claims of novelty should always be supported by comparison with previous literature rather than by subjective assertions. Authors should clearly articulate the expected theoretical, methodological, practical, educational, technological, or policy contributions of the research to highlight its scientific value and relevance.

The final paragraph of the Introduction should clearly state the objectives of the study and, where appropriate, present the research questions or hypotheses that guide the investigation. The objectives should emerge logically from the identified research gap and should correspond directly to the research design and analytical procedures described in the Methodology section. Authors are encouraged to conclude the Introduction by briefly explaining the anticipated contribution of the study and, if considered helpful for readers, providing a concise overview of the organization of the manuscript.

Throughout the Introduction, authors should maintain logical coherence between paragraphs by using appropriate transition sentences that connect ideas naturally and systematically. Every paragraph should contribute directly to the development of the research argument and ultimately lead readers to understand the necessity, originality, and significance of the study. Excessive background information, lengthy theoretical explanations unrelated to the research objectives, descriptive summaries of previous studies, unsupported opinions, promotional language, and unnecessary quotations should be avoided. Instead, the Introduction should present a balanced, evidence-based, and persuasive scholarly narrative that establishes a strong scientific justification for the research and prepares readers for the subsequent sections of the manuscript.

 

LITERATURE REVIEW

(Cambria, 12 PT, Capital Each Word, Justified, 1.15 Spacing)

The Literature Review provides the theoretical and empirical foundation of the study by critically examining existing knowledge relevant to the research topic. Rather than serving as a descriptive summary of previous studies, this section should demonstrate the author's ability to synthesize, compare, evaluate, and integrate scholarly literature to establish the intellectual context of the research. Authors should explain how existing theories, concepts, and empirical findings relate to the research problem while identifying areas of agreement, inconsistency, methodological limitations, and unresolved issues that justify the present study. The review should progressively guide readers toward a clear understanding of the theoretical framework underpinning the research and illustrate how the current study extends, refines, or challenges previous knowledge. Whenever appropriate, authors are encouraged to organize the discussion thematically or conceptually instead of chronologically, allowing stronger analytical connections among studies. The literature cited should primarily consist of recent, peer-reviewed journal articles indexed in internationally recognized databases such as Scopus or Web of Science, with approximately 70–80% of references published within the last five to ten years, except for seminal works or foundational theories that remain highly relevant to the discipline. Authors should prioritize original research articles over textbooks, unpublished reports, or non-academic sources, ensuring that every citation directly contributes to the development of the research argument. The review should not merely describe previous findings but should critically evaluate their strengths, weaknesses, methodological approaches, theoretical perspectives, and practical implications. Particular attention should be given to identifying theoretical, methodological, empirical, or contextual research gaps that remain insufficiently addressed in existing literature. These gaps should emerge naturally from the critical synthesis and provide a convincing rationale for the present investigation. The section should conclude by establishing the conceptual or theoretical framework that guides the study and by demonstrating how the proposed research contributes to the advancement of knowledge, professional practice, educational innovation, technological development, or policy formulation. Throughout the Literature Review, authors should maintain logical coherence between paragraphs, use formal and objective academic language, avoid excessive quotations or lengthy summaries of individual studies, and ensure that all arguments are supported by credible scholarly evidence. A well-developed Literature Review should ultimately convince readers that the study is grounded in current scientific knowledge while clearly demonstrating the necessity, originality, and scholarly contribution of the research.

 

METHODOLOGY

(Cambria, 12 PT, Capital Each Word, Justified, 1.15 Spacing)

The Methodology section should provide a clear, comprehensive, and transparent description of how the study was designed, conducted, and analyzed, enabling readers to evaluate the scientific rigor of the research and, where appropriate, replicate the study. Authors should describe the research design and justify its suitability for addressing the research objectives or hypotheses, followed by a detailed explanation of the research setting, participants or data sources, population and sampling procedures, inclusion and exclusion criteria, research instruments, variables or units of analysis, data collection procedures, ethical considerations, and analytical techniques employed. The methodology should be sufficiently detailed to ensure reproducibility while remaining concise and focused on information that directly supports the validity and reliability of the study. Authors should clearly identify the research approach, whether quantitative, qualitative, mixed methods, experimental, quasi-experimental, survey, case study, phenomenology, grounded theory, ethnography, action research, design and development research, systematic review, meta-analysis, or other appropriate designs, and explain why the selected approach is the most suitable for answering the research questions. When questionnaires, tests, observation sheets, interview protocols, or other instruments are used, information regarding instrument development or adaptation, validity, reliability, pilot testing, and measurement procedures should be provided. Studies involving human participants must include a statement describing ethical approval, informed consent, confidentiality, anonymity, and compliance with relevant institutional or international ethical standards. Authors should also explain the statistical analyses or qualitative analytical procedures employed, including the software packages used, assumptions tested where applicable, significance levels, effect size measures, confidence intervals, coding procedures, thematic analysis, content analysis, grounded theory procedures, or other analytical techniques relevant to the research design. For mixed-methods research, the integration of quantitative and qualitative findings should be clearly described. Methodological descriptions should be written in the past tense, using clear and objective academic language without reporting research findings or discussing their implications, which belong in subsequent sections. Sufficient detail should be provided to enable readers to understand the research process and assess the credibility, trustworthiness, validity, reliability, and overall quality of the investigation while ensuring consistency between the stated objectives, research design, data collection procedures, analytical methods, and reported findings.

 

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

(Cambria, 12 PT, Capital Each Word, Justified, 1.15 Spacing)

Result

The Results and Discussion section constitutes the core of the manuscript and should present the research findings in a logical, systematic, and coherent manner while providing a critical interpretation of their academic significance. Authors should report the results objectively and ensure that every finding directly addresses the research objectives, questions, or hypotheses established in the Introduction. Findings should be presented before they are interpreted, allowing readers to distinguish clearly between empirical evidence and scholarly interpretation. Results may be organized using subheadings corresponding to research questions, hypotheses, themes, variables, or analytical procedures to enhance readability and facilitate logical progression throughout the manuscript. Quantitative studies should report descriptive and inferential statistical results, including appropriate measures such as means, standard deviations, confidence intervals, effect sizes, significance levels, regression coefficients, model fit indices, or other relevant statistical parameters. Qualitative studies should present major themes, categories, or patterns supported by representative quotations or observational evidence while maintaining participant confidentiality. Mixed-methods studies should clearly demonstrate the integration of quantitative and qualitative findings and explain how both forms of evidence complement one another in addressing the research objectives.

Discussion

The discussion should move beyond merely describing the results by critically interpreting their meaning within the context of existing scholarly knowledge. Authors should explain how the findings support, extend, refine, or challenge previous studies and relevant theoretical frameworks, highlighting both consistencies and discrepancies with earlier research. Differences between the present findings and prior literature should be discussed analytically rather than descriptively, considering possible methodological, contextual, cultural, or theoretical explanations. Authors are encouraged to relate their findings to internationally recognized theories and contemporary empirical evidence, thereby demonstrating the scientific contribution of the study to the advancement of knowledge within the discipline. Particular emphasis should be placed on the originality of the findings and their implications for theory development, methodological improvement, professional practice, educational innovation, technological advancement, or public policy, depending on the scope of the research.

When discussing the results, authors should avoid repeating numerical data already presented in tables or figures. Instead, the narrative should emphasize the interpretation, significance, and implications of the findings. Every table and figure should be explicitly cited within the text and should complement rather than duplicate the written explanation. Tables and figures should be presented in sequential order, include concise yet informative titles and notes where necessary, and conform to the journal's formatting requirements. Authors should ensure that all statistical analyses are reported completely and transparently, including assumptions, effect sizes, confidence intervals, or other indicators appropriate to the research design. For qualitative studies, sufficient evidence should be provided to support each theme or interpretation while maintaining analytical depth rather than merely presenting participant quotations.

The section should conclude by synthesizing the principal findings and demonstrating how they collectively address the research problem identified in the Introduction. Authors should explain the broader significance of the findings, acknowledge any unexpected or contradictory results where appropriate, discuss practical applications, and identify limitations that may influence the interpretation or generalizability of the study. Rather than making unsupported claims, interpretations should remain proportional to the evidence presented and should be supported by relevant scholarly literature. Throughout the Results and Discussion section, authors should maintain a clear distinction between factual findings and interpretative arguments, employ precise and objective academic language, and ensure logical coherence between the reported results, the discussion, and the overall conclusions of the manuscript. A well-developed Results and Discussion section should not only demonstrate what was discovered but also explain why the findings are scientifically meaningful, how they contribute to existing knowledge, and what implications they hold for future research and professional practice.

 

CONCLUSION

(Cambria, 12 PT, Capital Each Word, Justified, 1.15 Spacing)

The Conclusion should provide a concise and comprehensive synthesis of the principal findings of the study while directly addressing the research objectives or questions presented in the Introduction. Rather than repeating the Results and Discussion section, the conclusion should emphasize the most important scientific insights derived from the research and explain their significance within the broader context of the discipline. Authors should clearly state how the findings contribute to theoretical development, methodological advancement, professional practice, educational innovation, technological application, or policy formulation, depending on the scope of the study. Any practical implications should be presented objectively and supported by the reported findings. Where appropriate, authors are encouraged to acknowledge the limitations of the study and briefly recommend directions for future research to address unresolved issues or extend the current investigation. The conclusion should not introduce new data, new interpretations, citations, or arguments that have not been discussed previously. Instead, it should provide a clear and balanced closing statement that reinforces the originality, contribution, and overall significance of the research.

 

Acknowledgements

(Cambria, 10 PT, Capital Each Word, Justified, 1.0 Spacing)

The Acknowledgements section provides authors with an opportunity to recognize individuals, institutions, organizations, laboratories, research assistants, technical staff, funding agencies, or collaborators who contributed substantially to the completion of the research but who do not meet the internationally accepted criteria for authorship. Authors should acknowledge only contributions that directly supported the research, such as technical assistance, data collection, statistical consultation, language editing, administrative support, access to research facilities, or institutional cooperation. Expressions of gratitude should remain professional, concise, and academically appropriate. Personal dedications, overly emotional statements, or acknowledgements unrelated to the research should be avoided. Where financial support has been received, the information presented in this section should remain consistent with the Funding Statement.

 

Funding Statement

(Cambria, 10 PT, Capital Each Word, Justified, 1.0 Spacing)

Authors are required to disclose all sources of financial support received during the conduct of the research in the interest of transparency and research integrity. The Funding Statement should identify the funding organization, sponsoring institution, grant number, contract number, or project identification number whenever applicable. If multiple funding sources supported the research, each source should be identified clearly. If the research did not receive any specific financial support from governmental agencies, commercial organizations, universities, foundations, or other funding bodies, authors should explicitly state that no specific funding was received. Complete and accurate funding disclosure assists readers in understanding the context of the research and complies with international publication ethics and indexing requirements.

 

CRediT Authorship Contribution Statement

(Cambria, 10 PT, Capital Each Word, Justified, 1.0 Spacing)

Authors are encouraged to describe individual contributions using the Contributor Roles Taxonomy (CRediT) to promote transparency and accountability in scholarly publishing. Each author's contribution should accurately reflect their intellectual and practical involvement in the research process, including roles such as conceptualization, methodology, software development, validation, formal analysis, investigation, resources, data curation, writing the original draft, reviewing and editing, visualization, supervision, project administration, and funding acquisition. Only contributors who satisfy the journal's authorship criteria should be included as authors. The CRediT statement should accurately represent the contribution of each author and should be approved by all authors before manuscript submission.

 

Declaration of AI-Assisted Writing

(Cambria, 10 PT, Capital Each Word, Justified, 1.0 Spacing)

Authors should disclose any use of artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted technologies that contributed to the preparation of the manuscript. Acceptable uses include language editing, grammar correction, readability improvement, translation assistance, coding support, or formatting, provided that all scientific content, data interpretation, conclusions, and intellectual contributions remain the responsibility of the human authors. Artificial intelligence tools must not be listed as authors and should not be used to generate, fabricate, manipulate, or falsify research data, references, results, analyses, or conclusions. Authors remain fully accountable for the originality, accuracy, integrity, and ethical compliance of the submitted manuscript. If no AI-assisted technologies were used during manuscript preparation, authors should explicitly state that no AI tools were used.

 

Declaration of Competing Interest

(Cambria, 10 PT, Capital Each Word, Justified, 1.0 Spacing)

Authors must disclose any financial, professional, institutional, or personal relationships that could reasonably be perceived as influencing the design, conduct, interpretation, or reporting of the research. Competing interests may include research funding, consulting fees, employment, advisory positions, stock ownership, patents, editorial responsibilities, or other affiliations that could create actual or perceived conflicts of interest. If no competing interests exist, authors should explicitly declare that they have no known competing financial or non-financial interests related to the submitted work. Transparent disclosure of competing interests strengthens the credibility, objectivity, and integrity of scholarly communication.

 

Data Availability Statement

(Cambria, 10 PT, Capital Each Word, Justified, 1.0 Spacing)

Authors should provide a clear statement regarding the availability of the research data supporting the findings of the study. Whenever possible, datasets should be deposited in an appropriate public repository and accompanied by a persistent identifier such as a DOI or accession number. If data are available upon reasonable request, the corresponding author should be identified as the contact person. Where data cannot be publicly shared because of confidentiality, ethical restrictions, legal obligations, institutional policies, or participant privacy considerations, authors should clearly explain these limitations. The Data Availability Statement should accurately reflect the accessibility of all underlying research materials and comply with the journal's data-sharing policy.

 

REFERENCES

(Cambria, 12 PT, Capital Each Word, Justified, 1.15 Spacing)

The References section should include only sources cited within the manuscript and should be prepared in accordance with the APA 7th edition referencing style unless otherwise specified by the journal. Authors are encouraged to prioritize high-quality, peer-reviewed scholarly literature indexed in internationally recognized databases such as Scopus and Web of Science. For original research articles, authors should cite a minimum of 30 references, with approximately 70–80% published within the last five to ten years, except for seminal theories or landmark publications that remain fundamental to the discipline. Every in-text citation must correspond to a complete reference entry, and all references should be presented alphabetically by the surname of the first author. Digital Object Identifiers (DOIs) should be included whenever available, and authors are encouraged to use reference management software such as Mendeley application to ensure accuracy and consistency. References should be carefully checked before submission to eliminate incomplete citations, duplicate entries, formatting inconsistencies, and inaccessible sources. Preference should be given to original research articles rather than secondary citations, unpublished materials, or non-academic websites, except where such sources are essential to the context of the study. A complete, accurate, and up-to-date reference list enhances the scientific credibility, traceability, and discoverability of the published manuscript.