About the Journal

Journal information & publication policies

Substantia: Jurnal Ilmu-Ilmu Ushuluddin

Aims and scope, submission requirements, publication charges, peer review, editorial ethics, and open-access policies.

Policy 01 / 21

Objectives and Scope

Substantia: Jurnal Ilmu-Ilmu Ushuluddin is a peer-reviewed, open-access scholarly journal published by the Faculty of Ushuluddin and Philosophy, Universitas Islam Negeri (UIN) Ar-Raniry, Banda Aceh, Indonesia. It publishes original scholarly contributions on the intellectual traditions, texts, practices, and contemporary transformations of Islam and religion.

Objectives

The journal promotes critical engagement with classical and contemporary scholarship, advances theoretical and methodological debates in Ushuluddin studies, and encourages research that connects Islamic intellectual traditions with social and cultural realities. Contributions are assessed for originality, relevance, analytical depth, evidentiary support, and their significance for an international scholarly readership.

Thematic Scope

  • Aqidah, Islamic theology, and religious thought.
  • Qur'anic studies, tafsir, and hadith studies.
  • Islamic philosophy, general philosophy, and intellectual history.
  • Islamic thought, literature, science, and civilization.
  • Islam, peace, and religion in local or national contexts.
  • Islam, gender, and contemporary socio-religious change.
  • Comparative religions and sociology of religion.
  • Mysticism, Sufism, and religious practices.

The journal welcomes empirical research, textual and historical investigations, comparative analysis, and theoretically engaged conceptual studies. Interdisciplinary manuscripts are considered when their contribution to the journal's fields is explicit. Submissions that merely summarize existing literature without an identifiable argument, research problem, or scholarly contribution do not satisfy the journal's academic expectations.

Policy 02 / 21

Authorship Criteria and Contributions

Authorship Eligibility

Authorship is reserved for individuals who make substantive scholarly contributions to the conception or design of the study, the acquisition or interpretation of evidence, or the development of its argument; participate in drafting or critically revising its intellectual content; approve the submitted and final versions; and accept accountability for the integrity of their contributions. All listed authors must consent to submission and the order of authorship.

Contributions and Acknowledgments

The corresponding author coordinates declarations, communicates editorial decisions, secures approval of each manuscript version, and provides accurate affiliations and contact information. Contributors whose assistance does not meet authorship requirements—including routine administrative support, translation, language editing, or research assistance—should be acknowledged with consent rather than added as authors. Funding and relevant institutional assistance must be disclosed.

Changes and Disputes

Requests to add, remove, or reorder authors after submission require an explanation and documented agreement from all affected authors. The editorial office may suspend consideration while a dispute is resolved. Where authors cannot establish an agreed attribution, the journal may refer the question to the relevant institution; editors do not arbitrate competing claims without sufficient evidence.

Artificial Intelligence

Generative AI systems, language models, and automated writing tools cannot qualify as authors. Human authors remain responsible for text, analysis, references, images, disclosure, and compliance with the journal's Generative AI Policy.

Policy 03 / 21

Manuscript Types

Research Articles

Original research articles present a defined scholarly problem, engage relevant literature, explain the research approach and evidence, and develop independently substantiated findings and implications. Applicable methods include textual, historical, philosophical, qualitative, quantitative, mixed-methods, and comparative approaches relevant to Ushuluddin studies.

Conceptual and Theoretical Studies

Conceptual articles contribute a clear and original analytical argument, theoretical reformulation, interpretive framework, or systematic scholarly critique. They must identify the literature or source corpus, explain the logic of analysis, and substantiate their conclusions. A descriptive overview alone is insufficient.

Book Reviews and Other Contributions

The journal's broader disciplinary scope encompasses critical engagement with scholarly books and debates. Any book review or other non-research contribution is considered only when the relevant submission section is available and the editorial office has accepted that content type. Such material must be accurately identified and is not represented as an externally peer-reviewed research article unless it has undergone the stated review process.

Common Submission Requirements

Full research manuscripts follow the journal's Author Guidelines, including academic integrity requirements, reference style, required declarations, and the manuscript template. The editorial office may return a submission that does not fit an available section or fails to present an identifiable scholarly contribution.

Policy 04 / 21

Publication Schedule

Substantia: Jurnal Ilmu-Ilmu Ushuluddin publishes two issues each year, in April and October. Each issue presents scholarly contributions that have completed editorial assessment, peer review, author revision, and production.

Editorial Schedule

Publication is determined by the journal's issue schedule and the readiness of accepted manuscripts. Acceptance of a manuscript does not guarantee placement in a specific issue. Manuscripts received after an issue's production deadline may be scheduled for the next available issue.

Publication Record

Published issues are organised by volume, issue, publication year, and article metadata in the journal's electronic archive. The publication date shown on each official article record is the date applicable to that article.

Policy 05 / 21

Digital Preservation and Archiving

Substantia maintains an electronic archive of published issues and article records through its official Open Journal Systems (OJS) platform. Available bibliographic metadata and full-text files remain associated with their respective volumes and issues.

Access and Record Integrity

Published records identify the article title, authors, issue details, and DOI where assigned. Editorial notices concerning corrections, expressions of concern, or retractions are linked to the affected article, allowing readers to follow the publication record.

Preservation and Recovery

The editorial office and publisher oversee continuity of access to journal-controlled content and address reports of inaccessible records or damaged files. Archival records are maintained as part of the journal's publishing responsibilities. Requests for access or correction of a broken article or DOI link may be sent through the journal's official contact.

Policy 07 / 21

Open License and Reuse

Articles published in Substantia: Jurnal Ilmu-Ilmu Ushuluddin are distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, as stated in the journal's Copyright Notice.

Permissions and Attribution

The license permits users to share and adapt licensed content for non-commercial purposes when they provide appropriate attribution, link to the license, and indicate whether changes were made. Commercial reuse requires separate permission from the copyright holder. Third-party material identified as excluded from the article's license remains subject to its own permissions.

Copyright Holder

Authors retain copyright and grant the journal the right of first publication. The terms stated on an article's official version of record apply to that article. The full licensing terms are available at Creative Commons CC BY-NC 4.0.

Policy 08 / 21

Plagiarism and Text Overlap Policy

All manuscripts submitted to Substantia must be original and accurately acknowledge the sources used. The journal screens submissions for text overlap, plagiarism, self-plagiarism, and duplicate publication using Turnitin or an equivalent similarity-detection system.

Similarity Requirement

The journal requires a similarity index below 25%. Editors examine the nature of any matched material, not only the numerical score. Properly quoted passages, reference lists, standard terms, and legitimate methodological descriptions are evaluated in context. A low score does not excuse unattributed copying, and an elevated score does not, by itself, prove misconduct.

Editorial Action

Submissions containing unacceptable overlap may be returned for correction or rejected according to the seriousness of the problem. Suspected deliberate plagiarism or duplicate submission is assessed under the journal's research misconduct procedures. Concerns identified after publication may result in correction, an expression of concern, or retraction as appropriate.

Policy 09 / 21

Allegations of Research Misconduct

Reportable Concerns

Substantia examines credible allegations of fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, unethical research involving human participants, manipulated images or records, undisclosed duplicate publication, serious authorship misrepresentation, citation manipulation, and other practices capable of compromising the scholarly record. Concerns may be raised before or after publication by authors, reviewers, editors, institutions, or readers.

Submission and Assessment of Allegations

A report should identify the manuscript or article and provide a specific description of the concern with available evidence. The editorial office records the allegation, protects sensitive information, assesses whether it falls within the journal's remit, and assigns the matter to an editor without a relevant conflict of interest. Anonymous reports may be assessed when the evidence can be evaluated.

Opportunity to Respond and Institutional Cooperation

Individuals concerned are given a reasonable opportunity to provide an explanation. For matters requiring access to original research records, institutional approvals, or interviews beyond the journal's authority, the editorial office may request assistance from the relevant research institution. An allegation alone is not a determination of wrongdoing.

Decisions and the Publication Record

Editorial action is proportionate to the evidence and the reliability of the work: requests for documentation, revision, rejection, correction, expression of concern, or retraction may be appropriate. The editor records the rationale and informs relevant parties within confidentiality and legal limits. Retractions protect the accuracy of the literature and are not imposed merely as punishment.

Policy 10 / 21

Conflicts of Interest

Disclosure by Authors

Authors must declare relationships or interests that might reasonably be perceived to influence the research or interpretation. These include financial support, employment, advisory roles, intellectual property, personal or professional relationships, institutional interests, and other relevant commitments. The absence of a conflict should also be stated when the submission system requires a declaration.

Editorial Independence

Editors assess submissions on scholarly merit and do not permit publication fees, institutional affiliation, sponsorship, or commercial considerations to determine acceptance. An editor with a relevant conflict must recuse themselves from the affected decision, and the manuscript is assigned to an appropriate independent editor.

Reviewer Conflicts

Reviewers must disclose relevant competing interests before accepting an invitation and decline work they cannot evaluate impartially. Previous collaboration, close relationships, direct intellectual competition, or other relationships affecting impartiality are considered in reviewer allocation. Reviewers may not use confidential knowledge obtained through peer review for personal advantage.

Management of Undeclared Interests

Where an interest emerges during review or after publication, the editor assesses whether the integrity of the assessment or published interpretation is affected. Actions may include a further review, updated disclosure, correction, or other integrity procedure. Disclosure does not automatically disqualify a study; failure to disclose a material conflict may warrant editorial action.

Policy 11 / 21

Post-Publication Discussion

Scholarly Responses

Substantia welcomes evidence-based post-publication debate about the arguments, methods, data, ethical aspects, and interpretations presented in its articles. Readers and authors may submit a reasoned response or a request for clarification through the editorial contact. A submission should identify the article and state the issue clearly, with supporting sources where appropriate.

Moderation and Author Response

The editorial office evaluates relevance, factual support, professional tone, confidentiality, and potential conflicts of interest before deciding whether to share a response with the authors or publish it in a suitable form. Responses containing personal attacks, harassment, confidential participant information, or unsupported allegations may be declined or returned for revision. Where material criticism is considered, the original authors are ordinarily offered an opportunity to respond.

Corrections and Integrity Concerns

A substantive factual or ethical problem is referred to the journal's correction, retraction, or research misconduct procedure as appropriate. Post-publication dialogue does not itself amend the published version of record; any editorial change is documented through a clearly linked notice.

Policy 12 / 21

Corrections, Retractions and Withdrawal

Withdrawal Before Publication

The corresponding author may request withdrawal of a manuscript that is still under consideration, explaining the reason and confirming co-author agreement. The editorial office confirms the submission status and records the outcome. Authors should not treat a pending request as completed or submit the same work elsewhere while its status remains unresolved.

Corrections

When a published article contains an error that requires public clarification but does not invalidate its central findings, the journal issues a correction notice identifying the article, the affected information, the correction, and the date. Significant changes are assessed by an editor, with specialist advice where necessary. The correction is linked bidirectionally with the article.

Expressions of Concern

An expression of concern may be issued when credible, substantial doubts remain unresolved and readers should be alerted while an investigation proceeds. The notice explains the nature of the concern without prejudging the outcome and may subsequently be updated or replaced by a correction or retraction.

Retractions

The journal retracts a publication when evidence establishes that its conclusions or key findings cannot be relied upon, including serious error, fabrication, falsification, substantial plagiarism, or other grounds that irreparably compromise the scholarly record. Retraction notices explain the reasons, identify who issues the notice, and remain publicly connected to the affected article. Retracted articles ordinarily remain accessible with prominent labelling rather than being silently deleted.

Exceptional Removal and Appeals

Removal from public access is exceptional and reserved for compelling legal, privacy, or safety reasons. Requests for reconsideration are evaluated using relevant evidence and an independent assessment of any material procedural error.

Policy 13 / 21

Peer Review Process

Substantia applies a double-blind peer review process. Authors' identities are concealed from reviewers, and reviewers' identities are not disclosed to authors during the assessment process.

Initial Editorial Screening

The editor assesses the suitability of the subject, originality, manuscript format, scholarly contribution, methodological coherence, ethical compliance, and similarity screening. A manuscript may be declined at this stage if it does not meet the journal's standards.

External Review

Manuscripts that pass screening are assigned to reviewers with expertise in the relevant subject area. Reviews consider originality, the appropriateness of theory and method, the quality of analysis, the strength of evidence and argument, and clarity of scholarly communication. Reviewers are expected to provide objective, reasoned, and confidential recommendations.

Decision and Revision

The editorial team evaluates reviewers' recommendations and communicates its decision to the corresponding author. Where revisions are required, authors should respond to substantive comments and identify the changes made. The editor may request further assessment before a final decision. The editor retains responsibility for acceptance or rejection.

Review Timeline

The normal screening and evaluation period is approximately three to five months from receipt of the manuscript. The duration may vary according to the availability of reviewers, the complexity of the submission, and the revisions required.

Policy 14 / 21

Open Access Policy

Substantia provides immediate open access to its published scholarly content. Readers may access available published articles and their full-text files online without a subscription or paywall. Open access supports the exchange of knowledge among scholars, educators, students, and the wider public.

Reading Access and Reuse

Free access to read and download an article is distinct from permission to reproduce or adapt it. Reuse is governed by the Creative Commons licence and copyright notice assigned to the particular article. For articles carrying CC BY-NC 4.0, reuse must be non-commercial, attributed, and compliant with the licence conditions.

Author Charges

Open access does not mean that all publishing services are free to authors. Under the journal's stated author fee schedule, submission is free and an article processing charge applies only to an accepted manuscript. The fees are stated separately in the Article Processing Charges policy. Payment has no bearing on the independent editorial decision.

Policy 15 / 21

Ownership and Editorial Management

Substantia: Jurnal Ilmu-Ilmu Ushuluddin (P-ISSN 1411-4976; E-ISSN 2356-1955) is published by the Faculty of Ushuluddin and Philosophy, Universitas Islam Negeri (UIN) Ar-Raniry, Banda Aceh, Indonesia. Established in 1999, the journal disseminates research and scholarly analysis across the Ushuluddin disciplines.

Editorial Leadership

Editor-in-Chief: Musdawati, Universitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry, Banda Aceh, Indonesia.
Managing Editor: Azwarfajri, Universitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry, Banda Aceh, Indonesia.

The full Editorial Team identifies additional editors and scholarly advisers; the Reviewers page presents the journal's reviewer directory.

Editorial Independence

The publisher is responsible for institutional oversight and publishing infrastructure. Editorial decisions are based on manuscript quality, the assessment of reviewers, relevance to the journal's scope, and publication ethics. The payment of an APC does not influence peer review or guarantee acceptance.

Policy 16 / 21

Contact Information

Editorial Office

Substantia: Jurnal Ilmu-Ilmu Ushuluddin
Faculty of Ushuluddin and Philosophy, Universitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry Banda Aceh
Gedung Fakultas Ushuluddin Lantai II, Jln. Lingkar Kampus, Kopelma Darussalam, Banda Aceh, Aceh 23111, Indonesia.

Principal Contact

Musdawati, Editor-in-Chief
Email: musda.wati@ar-raniry.ac.id
Telephone: +62 881-0249-12434

Editorial and Technical Support

OJS Manager
Email: substantia.adm@gmail.com

Official correspondence about editorial decisions, publication charges, corrections, complaints, and the integrity of published articles should be directed through the journal's established editorial channels. Include the submission ID, article title, or DOI when available. Do not transmit sensitive participant records through publicly visible comments.

See the Contact page for the journal's current contact directory.

Policy 17 / 21

Article Processing Charges and Fees

Fee Schedule

Fee category Amount
Manuscript submission fee IDR 0
Article Processing Charge (APC) for an accepted article IDR 800,000
Subscription or reader access IDR 0

Substantia does not charge an article submission fee. An Article Processing Charge of IDR 800,000 is payable only after the manuscript has been accepted for publication. The APC relates to the journal's publication services and does not influence editorial screening, the outcome of peer review, or acceptance decisions.

Payment Procedure

Authors should make payment only in response to formal billing or payment instructions communicated by the authorised editorial office after acceptance. The journal does not require payment to secure a positive peer-review report or to obtain an acceptance decision. Authors should verify any unexpected payment request with the editorial office using the official contact information.

Transparency

The stated APC is separate from any independent professional services, such as translation or manuscript preparation, obtained voluntarily by an author. Such services do not guarantee acceptance. All payments associated with journal publication must be explained transparently before they are requested.

Policy 18 / 21

Author Guidelines

Originality, Scope, and Languages

Authors must submit original scholarly work relevant to Substantia's focus and scope. A manuscript must not have been published or be under consideration by another journal. The journal accepts manuscripts written in Indonesian, English, or Arabic.

Manuscript Format

  • Length: 4,000–7,000 words (approximately 15–25 pages).
  • Page and font: A4 paper, Times New Roman, 12 pt, single-spaced, following the journal template.
  • Title: informative, clear, and no more than 15 words; avoid abbreviations.
  • Author information: names without academic titles, institutional affiliations, email address, and contact information in the submission metadata as requested by the journal.
  • Abstracts: Indonesian and English, one paragraph each, maximum 300 words, presenting context, objective, method, findings, and conclusion without citations.
  • Keywords: 3–7 terms.
  • Structure: Title; Authors; Abstracts and Keywords; Introduction; Method; Results and Discussion; Conclusion; References.

Section Requirements

The Introduction presents the research problem, urgency, previous studies, purpose, and argument (maximum 1,000 words). The Method explains the research approach, setting or textual corpus, source selection, evidence collection, and analytical process (maximum 500 words). Results and Discussion provide evidence, analysis, and engagement with relevant studies. The Conclusion directly answers the research problem and identifies limitations (maximum 250 words).

Citations and References

Submissions must follow the Chicago Manual of Style, 17th Edition (Full Note) and use the Mendeley reference manager. The reference list must contain at least 25 sources, with approximately 80% scholarly journal articles and 20% books or other relevant sources. Qur'anic, Arabic and Indonesian transliterations follow the journal's prescribed Arabic–Latin transliteration rules based on the joint ministerial decree (SKB Tiga Menteri).

Submission and Review

Authors must use the journal's manuscript template and submit the manuscript together with the required author metadata through the OJS submission system. Submissions are subject to originality screening and double-blind peer review. Authors must declare relevant funding, competing interests, necessary research ethics approvals and consent, and substantive use of generative AI where applicable.

Policy 19 / 21

Article Usage and Visit Statistics

Substantia: Jurnal Ilmu-Ilmu Ushuluddin provides open access to published article records, full-text files, and available article-level readership statistics.

Website Visitor Statistics

Public website traffic information is available through the journal's visitor statistics dashboard. The dashboard presents available information about page views, visitor sessions, and visits based on its measurement configuration.

Article Views and Downloads

Article records may also display view and download counts. These indicators describe use of the online journal; they are not equivalent to citations or indicators of the scholarly quality of an article.

Policy 20 / 21

Abstracting, Indexing and Discoverability

Substantia: Jurnal Ilmu-Ilmu Ushuluddin supports the discoverability of published research through bibliographic metadata, scholarly search services, and library catalogues.

Abstracting and Discovery Services

Journal content is represented in academic discovery services including SINTA, GARUDA, Google Scholar, MORAREF, ONEsearch, Dimensions, Semantic Scholar, ResearchBib, EuroPub, and other academic catalogues. The journal maintains a public Abstracting and Indexing directory.

Bibliographic Identifiers

Print ISSN: 1411-4976.
Electronic ISSN: 2356-1955.

Article records include titles, authors, publication dates, issue and page information, and DOI identifiers where assigned, enabling reliable citation and scholarly retrieval.

Policy 21 / 21

Generative AI Policy

Human Authorship and Accountability

Substantia permits responsible use of generative artificial intelligence where it does not replace human scholarly judgment or compromise research integrity. Authors remain fully accountable for every claim, reference, quotation, analysis, translation, illustration, and conclusion. An AI tool cannot be listed as an author and cannot approve a manuscript or assume responsibility for its accuracy.

Disclosure of Substantive Use

Authors must disclose substantial assistance from generative AI, stating the tool name and, where available, version; the purpose of use; the manuscript sections or outputs affected; and the steps taken to verify accuracy. Routine spelling, punctuation, or grammar assistance that does not alter intellectual content does not require the same disclosure. When an AI system forms part of the research method, its role, settings, inputs, evaluation, and limitations must be described in the Method section.

Prohibited and Unacceptable Practices

AI must not be used to fabricate data, invent interviews or participant statements, generate fictitious citations, simulate findings as real observations, or conceal unattributed borrowing from published works. Synthetic images, translations, textual excerpts, and illustrative examples must not be represented as authentic historical documents, manuscripts, or field evidence.

Sources in Islamic and Religious Studies

Quotations from Qur'anic verses, hadith, tafsir works, classical texts, and academic references must be checked against reliable source editions and fully attributed. AI-generated transliteration, translation, bibliographic details, and claims about transmission or textual history require independent verification. The existence of a plausible-looking reference is not evidence that a source exists or supports the claim.

Privacy and Confidential Peer Review

Authors must protect personal data, confidential research materials, and intellectual property when interacting with AI services. Editors and reviewers may not upload unpublished manuscripts or confidential review reports to public generative AI services. Editorial and peer-review judgments must remain independent human assessments. Any suspicion of inappropriate AI use is evaluated on specific evidence, with an opportunity for author explanation; detection scores alone do not establish misconduct.