Publication Ethics

Substantia: Jurnal Ilmu-Ilmu Ushuluddin is a peer-reviewed scholarly journal published by the Faculty of Ushuluddin and Philosophy, Universitas Islam Negeri (UIN) Ar-Raniry, Banda Aceh, Indonesia. The journal is committed to maintaining integrity, transparency, fairness, and accountability throughout the scholarly publication process.

This publication ethics policy establishes the responsibilities of authors, editors, peer reviewers, and the publisher. It is informed by the principles and guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and applies to manuscripts submitted for consideration as well as articles published in the journal.

Policy Contents

1. Editorial Responsibilities and Independence

The Editor-in-Chief and Editorial Board are responsible for ensuring that editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit, originality, relevance to the journal's scope, methodological rigor, ethical compliance, and the quality of the evidence and arguments presented.

  • Editorial independence: Editorial decisions are made independently of commercial, financial, institutional, or personal interests. Payment of publication charges does not influence manuscript acceptance.
  • Fair evaluation: Manuscripts are evaluated without discrimination based on gender, ethnicity, nationality, religious affiliation, political beliefs, institutional affiliation, or other characteristics unrelated to scholarly quality.
  • Confidentiality: Information about submitted manuscripts is disclosed only to individuals legitimately involved in editorial assessment, peer review, publication, or an authorized ethics investigation.
  • Conflict management: Editors must disclose actual or potential conflicts of interest and withdraw from handling manuscripts when their impartiality could reasonably be questioned.
  • Decision-making: Editors consider reviewers' assessments and the journal's editorial standards but retain responsibility for the final publication decision.
  • Editorial integrity: Editors must address credible concerns about submitted or published research and take appropriate corrective action when necessary.

Unpublished manuscripts, research findings, and ideas obtained through editorial duties must not be used for personal research or other purposes without the authors' explicit permission.

2. Responsibilities of Peer Reviewers

Substantia applies a double-blind peer review process. Reviewers contribute to editorial decisions by providing objective, independent, constructive, and evidence-based evaluations of manuscripts.

  • Reviewers must maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts and all associated materials.
  • Reviewers should accept assignments only when they possess appropriate expertise and can complete the evaluation within the agreed period.
  • Reviews must address the manuscript's originality, theoretical contribution, methodology, evidence, analysis, interpretation, and presentation.
  • Reviewers must provide clear reasons for their assessments and avoid personal criticism, discriminatory statements, or inappropriate language.
  • Reviewers should identify substantial uncited scholarly contributions, suspected plagiarism, overlapping publication, or other potential ethical concerns.
  • Reviewers must disclose conflicts of interest and decline assignments where independent judgment cannot be maintained.
  • Reviewers must not exploit confidential manuscripts, data, arguments, or findings for personal or professional advantage.
  • Reviewers must not request unnecessary citations to their own work or to particular journals for the purpose of manipulating citation metrics.

Reviewers must not share manuscripts with unauthorized individuals or upload confidential materials to generative AI services where confidentiality cannot be assured without prior authorization from the journal and the authors' permission where required.

3. Responsibilities of Authors

Authors are responsible for the originality, accuracy, transparency, and integrity of their submitted work. Manuscripts must accurately represent the research undertaken, the evidence obtained, and the scholarly arguments developed.

  • Authors must submit original work that has not been published previously or submitted simultaneously to another journal.
  • Research questions, methods, sources, findings, and interpretations must be reported accurately and consistently.
  • Authors must distinguish their original contributions from ideas, arguments, quotations, and data obtained from other sources.
  • Sources must be appropriately cited, and all necessary permissions must be obtained for copyrighted materials.
  • Authors must disclose relevant funding, competing interests, and substantive contributions from individuals who do not qualify for authorship.
  • Authors must cooperate with editorial inquiries, peer review, requests for clarification, and investigations concerning research integrity.
  • Authors who discover significant errors in submitted or published work must promptly notify the editorial office.

Authors remain accountable for the content of their manuscripts, including materials prepared with the assistance of third parties or digital technologies.

4. Authorship and Contributorship

Authorship is reserved for individuals who have made substantial scholarly contributions to the research and manuscript and who accept responsibility for their contributions to the published work.

Qualifying contributions may include the conception and design of the research, collection or interpretation of evidence, substantive analysis, drafting or critical revision of the manuscript, and approval of the final version.

All listed authors must approve the manuscript before submission and agree to its publication. The corresponding author is responsible for ensuring that all eligible contributors are appropriately recognized and that no individual is included as an author without a legitimate contribution.

Honorary, guest, gift, and ghost authorship are unacceptable. Individuals who provide technical assistance, administrative support, language editing, or other contributions insufficient for authorship should be acknowledged appropriately, with their permission.

Requests to add, remove, or rearrange authors after submission must be supported by a clear explanation and agreement among the affected authors. Unresolved authorship disputes may be referred to the relevant institutions for assessment.

5. Originality, Plagiarism, and Similarity Screening

Substantia does not accept plagiarism, self-plagiarism, unattributed paraphrasing, substantial unacknowledged reproduction of published material, or the misrepresentation of another person's intellectual contribution as original work.

Submitted manuscripts undergo similarity screening using plagiarism detection software, including Turnitin or comparable tools, before proceeding to peer review. The journal requires a similarity index below 25%.

Similarity reports are examined in context. A numerical similarity score does not, by itself, establish whether plagiarism has occurred. Editors assess the nature, extent, and attribution of overlapping material, including quotations, references, methodological descriptions, and previously published content.

Manuscripts containing plagiarism or significant unattributed overlap are rejected. Where concerns arise after publication, the journal investigates the matter and may publish a correction, expression of concern, or retraction, as appropriate.

6. Duplicate Submission and Redundant Publication

Simultaneous submission of the same manuscript to multiple journals is prohibited. Authors must not publish substantially identical findings, analyses, or arguments in multiple publications without appropriate disclosure, justification, and acknowledgment of the original work.

When a manuscript is substantially related to previously published or concurrently prepared work, authors must disclose the relationship and provide the relevant materials to the editor.

Legitimate secondary analyses, expanded studies, or substantially new interpretations may be considered when their distinct scholarly contribution is clearly established and relevant prior publications are properly cited. The editorial team assesses potential overlap and determines whether the submission constitutes an independent scholarly contribution.

7. Research Integrity, Data, and Scholarly Evidence

Authors must maintain the integrity of all data, documents, textual sources, observations, interviews, translations, visual materials, and analytical records used to support their conclusions.

Fabrication, falsification, selective alteration of evidence, deceptive image manipulation, invented interview statements, and misrepresentation of research procedures are prohibited.

Research methods must be described in sufficient detail to permit scholarly evaluation. For qualitative, historical, philological, philosophical, and textual research, authors should identify the relevant sources, selection procedures, interpretive approaches, and analytical steps appropriate to the study.

Where relevant, authors must distinguish primary materials from secondary interpretations and accurately represent quotations, translations, archival documents, scriptural passages, and scholarly positions.

Editors may request supporting research materials or clarification when questions arise about the reliability or integrity of published findings, subject to confidentiality, privacy, copyright, and applicable ethical restrictions.

8. Research Ethics and Protection of Participants

Research involving human participants must respect their dignity, autonomy, privacy, cultural circumstances, and personal safety.

Authors must obtain informed consent where required, explain the purpose and nature of participation, and protect confidential or identifiable information. Additional safeguards must be applied when research involves children, vulnerable populations, or sensitive religious and social experiences.

Ethical approval from a competent institutional body must be obtained when required by applicable regulations or institutional policies. Authors should identify relevant approvals or explain the ethical safeguards used in studies for which formal review is not required.

The publication of identifiable photographs, personal narratives, interview excerpts, or sensitive information must comply with applicable consent and confidentiality requirements. The editorial team may request evidence of ethical compliance when necessary.

9. Conflicts of Interest and Funding Disclosure

Authors, reviewers, and editors must disclose financial, professional, institutional, academic, personal, or other interests that could influence, or reasonably appear to influence, the presentation, evaluation, or publication of scholarly work.

Authors must declare relevant funding sources and disclose any role played by sponsors in the research design, collection and analysis of evidence, interpretation of findings, preparation of the manuscript, or decision to submit the work.

Reviewers and editors must disclose competing interests before participating in manuscript evaluation. When a conflict may compromise independent judgment, the assignment must be declined or transferred to an appropriately independent individual.

The existence of a declared conflict does not necessarily prevent publication; however, transparency is required, and the editorial team may adopt safeguards to protect the integrity of the review and publication process.

10. Generative Artificial Intelligence in Scholarly Publishing

Generative artificial intelligence and AI-assisted technologies may support limited aspects of manuscript preparation, such as language improvement, grammar correction, and editorial assistance. Their use must not compromise the originality, accuracy, transparency, or integrity of scholarly work.

Authors must disclose substantive uses of generative AI, including the name of the tool, its purpose, and the extent of its contribution. AI tools cannot be listed as authors because they cannot accept accountability for research integrity or publication ethics.

Authors remain fully responsible for verifying all AI-assisted content, including quotations, citations, references, translations, interpretations, and analytical claims. Fabricated sources, invented research data, simulated interviews presented as genuine evidence, and misleading AI-generated visual materials are prohibited.

Editors and reviewers must preserve manuscript confidentiality when using digital tools. Confidential submissions must not be uploaded to third-party AI systems without appropriate authorization and adequate safeguards.

11. Allegations of Research and Publication Misconduct

Substantia takes credible allegations of research and publication misconduct seriously, whether they concern submitted manuscripts, published articles, editorial conduct, peer review, or the inappropriate use of scholarly materials.

Potential misconduct includes, but is not limited to, plagiarism, data fabrication or falsification, manipulated peer review, undisclosed duplicate publication, citation manipulation, unethical treatment of research participants, fraudulent authorship, and material misrepresentation of research findings.

Concerns may be submitted by authors, reviewers, readers, institutions, or other parties through the journal's official contact channels. Reports should identify the work or conduct concerned and provide supporting information where available.

The editorial response follows these principles:

  1. Preliminary assessment: The editor evaluates whether the allegation is sufficiently specific and credible to warrant further examination.
  2. Evidence and confidentiality: Relevant records are assessed with appropriate protection for complainants, authors, reviewers, and other individuals involved.
  3. Right of response: Individuals whose conduct is questioned are given a reasonable opportunity to explain the circumstances and provide supporting evidence.
  4. Independent assessment: Individuals with conflicts of interest do not determine the outcome. External expertise or institutional investigation may be sought when necessary.
  5. Editorial action: Depending on the findings, the journal may reject a submission, request clarification or revision, issue a correction or expression of concern, retract an article, or refer the matter to an appropriate institution.

Allegations are assessed fairly and proportionately. A concern or allegation is not treated as proof of misconduct. The journal follows relevant COPE guidance in determining an appropriate response.

12. Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions

Substantia is committed to preserving the integrity and transparency of the scholarly record. Errors or ethical concerns discovered after publication are addressed according to their nature, seriousness, and effect on the reliability of the published work.

Corrections

A correction may be published when an identified error requires public clarification or amendment but does not invalidate the central findings, conclusions, or scholarly contribution of the article.

Expressions of Concern

An expression of concern may be issued when there are substantial unresolved questions about a published article and an investigation is ongoing or cannot reach a reliable conclusion.

Retractions

Retraction may be necessary when findings are unreliable because of serious errors or misconduct, when substantial plagiarism or redundant publication is established, or when major ethical violations undermine the integrity of the publication.

Notices of correction, expression of concern, or retraction are clearly identified, publicly accessible, and linked to the affected article. Such notices explain the reason for the editorial action in objective language and identify the affected publication.

Retracted articles ordinarily remain accessible as part of the scholarly record, clearly marked as retracted. Removal of content is reserved for exceptional circumstances involving legal requirements, serious privacy risks, or other compelling grounds.

13. Complaints, Appeals, and Post-Publication Concerns

Authors may appeal editorial decisions when they believe that a material error, procedural irregularity, or significant misunderstanding has affected the evaluation of their manuscript.

Appeals must be submitted in writing through the journal's official contact channels and must clearly identify the manuscript, the decision being contested, and the reasons supported by relevant evidence.

Appeals are considered on their substantive and procedural merits. Where necessary, the journal may seek an independent assessment. An appeal does not guarantee reversal of the original editorial decision.

Readers, researchers, and other interested parties may also raise post-publication concerns regarding errors, evidence, interpretation, research integrity, or publication ethics.

Substantive post-publication discussions are evaluated by the editorial team. Depending on their nature, they may result in a published scholarly response, a clarification, a correction, or another appropriate editorial action.

14. Publisher Responsibilities and Editorial Accountability

The Faculty of Ushuluddin and Philosophy, Universitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry, as the journal's publishing institution, supports the integrity, independence, and continuity of the editorial process.

The publisher and editorial team share responsibility for maintaining transparent publication policies, protecting confidential editorial information, respecting intellectual property, and responding appropriately to credible concerns about published content.

Commercial considerations, including publication fees, must not determine the acceptance or rejection of scholarly manuscripts. Publication decisions remain based on editorial assessment, peer review, and compliance with academic and ethical standards.

When ethical concerns require institutional involvement, the journal may cooperate with relevant research institutions, publishers, or competent authorities while respecting confidentiality and procedural fairness.

Ethics Inquiries and Contact

Questions, complaints, allegations of misconduct, requests for correction, and appeals concerning publication ethics may be submitted to the editorial office of Substantia: Jurnal Ilmu-Ilmu Ushuluddin.

Editorial Office: Faculty of Ushuluddin and Philosophy, Universitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry, Banda Aceh, Indonesia.

Email: substantia.adm@gmail.com

Contact Information: Journal Contact Page

Ethical Framework and Reference Standards

This policy is informed by the principles of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), including its guidance on authorship, peer review, research misconduct, editorial independence, and post-publication corrections, as well as internationally recognized recommendations concerning the responsible use of artificial intelligence in scholarly publishing.