Peer Review Process

Substantia applies a double-blind peer review process. Authors' identities are concealed from reviewers, and reviewers' identities are not disclosed to authors during the assessment process.

Initial Editorial Screening

The editor assesses the suitability of the subject, originality, manuscript format, scholarly contribution, methodological coherence, ethical compliance, and similarity screening. A manuscript may be declined at this stage if it does not meet the journal's standards.

External Review

Manuscripts that pass screening are assigned to reviewers with expertise in the relevant subject area. Reviews consider originality, the appropriateness of theory and method, the quality of analysis, the strength of evidence and argument, and clarity of scholarly communication. Reviewers are expected to provide objective, reasoned, and confidential recommendations.

Decision and Revision

The editorial team evaluates reviewers' recommendations and communicates its decision to the corresponding author. Where revisions are required, authors should respond to substantive comments and identify the changes made. The editor may request further assessment before a final decision. The editor retains responsibility for acceptance or rejection.

Review Timeline

The normal screening and evaluation period is approximately three to five months from receipt of the manuscript. The duration may vary according to the availability of reviewers, the complexity of the submission, and the revisions required.