Publication Ethics

Publication Ethics and Editorial Independence Authorship Criteria and Contributorship Originality, Plagiarism, and Overlapping Publication Research Integrity and Reporting Standards Ethical Oversight, Consent, and Vulnerable Participants Conflicts of Interest and Funding Disclosure Duties of Editors and Publisher Duties of Peer Reviewers Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence Allegations of Research and Publication Misconduct Complaints and Appeals Post-Publication Discussion Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions Data Availability, Reproducibility, and Confidentiality Policy Framework

Publication Ethics and Editorial Independence

TAFSE: Journal of Qur’anic Studies is committed to responsible scholarly publication and the integrity of the academic record. Its publication ethics are informed by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing. This commitment describes editorial standards; it does not imply that TAFSE is a member of COPE.

Editorial decisions are based on the relevance, originality, scholarly quality, methodological adequacy, and ethical integrity of a submission. Publication fees, institutional position, personal relationships, and commercial considerations must not determine whether a manuscript is accepted. Editors evaluate manuscripts fairly without discrimination based on race, ethnicity, gender, nationality, religion, institutional affiliation, or political perspective.

Authorship Criteria and Contributorship

Authorship is restricted to persons who made a substantial intellectual contribution to the design, sources, data collection, analysis, interpretation, or writing of the study; approved the submitted and final versions; and accept responsibility for the parts of the work to which they contributed. All individuals meeting the criteria must be included, and honorary, gift, guest, and ghost authorship are not permitted.

The corresponding author is responsible for confirming all co-authors’ agreement to the author order, the content of the manuscript, and its submission. Editorial or technical support that does not satisfy authorship criteria should be acknowledged with appropriate permission. Proposed additions, removals, or reordering of authors after submission require a reasoned request and the written agreement of all affected authors; the editor evaluates the request before implementing any change.

Automated or generative AI systems cannot be listed as authors because they cannot accept responsibility for the reliability and integrity of the research.

Originality, Plagiarism, and Overlapping Publication

Authors must submit original work and appropriately cite quotations, paraphrases, data, ideas, images, and previously published interpretations. Plagiarism, fabricated citations, unattributed textual reuse, duplicate publication, redundant publication, and simultaneous submission to multiple journals are prohibited.

Manuscripts may be screened using Turnitin, as described in the journal’s established policy. A similarity percentage is a screening indicator, not a stand-alone finding of plagiarism. Editors assess the location, purpose, attribution, amount, and significance of matching text or material before reaching a decision. The journal does not assert a fixed numerical rejection threshold in this revised policy.

Authors must disclose related preprints, repository deposits, conference papers, theses, datasets, and articles that overlap materially with the submitted work. Legitimate scholarly reuse is evaluated according to attribution, transparency, copyright permissions, and the novelty of the submission.

Research Integrity and Reporting Standards

Authors must present research methods, sources, data, analyses, and findings accurately, without fabrication, falsification, selective misrepresentation, or manipulation of evidence. Claims about Qur’anic texts and exegetical literature must distinguish original textual evidence, historical interpretation, translation, and the authors’ analytical conclusions.

Authors should preserve underlying research records for a reasonable period and provide additional methodological details or available materials for confidential editorial verification when justified. Confidential data, unpublished manuscripts, and culturally sensitive materials must not be disclosed in violation of ethical commitments or applicable law.

Ethical Oversight, Consent, and Vulnerable Participants

Research involving human participants, including interviews, focus groups, observations, surveys, and digital ethnography, must follow applicable institutional and national ethical requirements. Authors must describe relevant ethical approval or explain why formal approval was not required, and should document informed consent as appropriate to the study design and participant population.

Researchers must take particular care when reporting on minors, people in dependent relationships, marginalized communities, or other vulnerable populations. Identifying information, images, audio, religious narratives, and interview excerpts require proportionate safeguards and consent to publication when participants could be recognized. Consent to participate in research does not automatically constitute consent to public identification.

Studies using publicly available digital content must still consider reasonable expectations of privacy, platform conditions, and risks of re-identification.

Conflicts of Interest and Funding Disclosure

Authors must disclose financial support and any financial, professional, personal, institutional, ideological, or other competing interest that readers might reasonably perceive as affecting the work. Where no competing interests exist, authors should state that fact. Funding statements should identify the supporting body and, when relevant, the funder’s role in study design, data handling, interpretation, and publication decisions.

Editors and reviewers must disclose potential conflicts before accepting an assignment. A conflicted editor should not manage the manuscript; an independent editor should oversee the assessment. Conflicted reviewers should decline the invitation or be replaced. Conflicts discovered after publication are evaluated for their possible effect on the scholarly record.

Duties of Editors and Publisher

  • Manage submissions impartially and maintain the independence of scholarly decisions.
  • Keep submitted materials, reviewer identities, and editorial correspondence confidential except where disclosure is required by a fair and lawful investigation.
  • Select qualified independent reviewers, assess the substance of their advice, and ensure that final editorial responsibility remains with the editor.
  • Avoid using unpublished materials or privileged information for personal research without the author’s explicit permission.
  • Address credible concerns about misconduct, peer review manipulation, or published errors without automatically presuming guilt.
  • Provide an avenue for complaints and appeals, and publish transparent corrections or retractions when warranted.
  • Protect scholarly freedom and the long-term accessibility of the publication record to the extent of the publisher’s responsibilities.

Duties of Peer Reviewers

  • Accept assignments only when appropriate expertise and sufficient time are available.
  • Treat manuscripts, data, identities, and review correspondence as confidential.
  • Evaluate scholarly merit objectively and support criticisms with specific evidence and reasoning; avoid personal or discriminatory comments.
  • Declare competing interests and decline assignments where impartiality may be compromised.
  • Identify overlooked relevant scholarship, possible duplication, or ethical concerns without independently contacting authors or investigating private information.
  • Do not reuse unpublished materials or upload confidential submissions to third-party AI tools without editorial authorization.

Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence

Human authors remain fully accountable for the accuracy, originality, citations, data, and interpretations in a submission. Substantive use of generative AI in manuscript drafting, translation, data analysis, image generation, or other research activities must be described in the appropriate manuscript section or acknowledgment, specifying the tool and purpose sufficiently for editorial evaluation. Routine spelling or grammar correction does not transfer authorship responsibility.

AI-generated references, quotations, Qur’anic citations, translations, summaries, and purported empirical findings must be checked against authentic sources. The fabrication of data, interviews, references, or textual evidence by AI is unacceptable. Editors and reviewers must not disclose confidential manuscripts to public AI systems without authorization and appropriate protection of the authors’ intellectual property and data.

Allegations of Research and Publication Misconduct

Concerns may include plagiarism, fabricated or falsified evidence, unethical research, citation manipulation, authorship fraud, undisclosed competing interests, compromised peer review, or systematic manipulation of submissions. Complaints should identify the manuscript or published work and provide enough detail or documentation for a responsible preliminary assessment.

  1. The editorial office records the concern, identifies the responsible editor, and assesses whether the allegation is specific and within the journal’s remit.
  2. Where appropriate, the editor preserves relevant records, requests a confidential explanation from affected parties, and obtains independent expert advice.
  3. The editor distinguishes an honest error from potential misconduct and avoids making disciplinary findings that belong to an employer, research institution, or competent authority.
  4. When a formal institutional investigation is appropriate, the journal may contact the institution or relevant authority and cooperate within legal and confidentiality constraints.
  5. The editor determines necessary editorial action, which may include no further action, clarification, correction, rejection, an expression of concern, or retraction, with reasons documented.

Allegations are assessed on their evidence. Confidentiality, fairness to all parties, and protection against retaliatory or malicious complaints guide the process.

Complaints and Appeals

Authors, reviewers, readers, and other concerned parties may submit a reasoned complaint through the journal’s official contact channel. Complaints can concern procedural irregularities, reviewer conduct, conflicts of interest, misconduct handling, publication delays, or post-publication action. The editorial office records the concern, examines supporting information, and responds with an explanation or a request for clarification.

An author appealing an editorial decision should identify the manuscript and explain a substantive factual or procedural error, rather than simply expressing disagreement with an unfavorable assessment. Where practicable, an appeal is reviewed by an editor who was not directly responsible for the contested decision. Complaints involving the Editor-in-Chief should be referred to an appropriate independent representative of the journal’s publisher. Appeals do not guarantee acceptance or a new review.

Post-Publication Discussion

TAFSE welcomes evidence-based scholarly discussion, reasoned criticism, requests for clarification, and reports of possible errors concerning its published articles. Readers may contact the editorial office through the journal’s official contact page, identifying the article, its DOI where available, and the specific issue to be considered.

The responsible editor may request an author response, seek independent advice, or arrange a formal correction, expression of concern, or retraction when necessary. Material comments and editorial responses may be made public in an appropriate journal format when publication is justified and confidentiality permits. This statement does not claim that a public comment module is enabled on the OJS website.

Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions

Correction: When a material error affects the record but does not invalidate the article’s main findings, the journal may publish a clearly labeled correction notice describing the change and linking it to the original article.

Expression of concern: When significant concerns about reliability or integrity remain unresolved and readers should be informed during an investigation, the journal may publish an appropriately qualified notice.

Retraction: Retraction may be necessary when the principal findings are unreliable, there is clear evidence of major misconduct or publication manipulation, or serious ethical or rights violations undermine the work. The aim is to correct the literature, not to punish authors. Retractions should be issued without unnecessary delay once the editorial basis is sufficient.

Published notices should be freely accessible, dated, clear about their reasons and initiator, and linked in both directions to the article wherever the platform permits. The bibliographic record should generally be retained with an explicit retraction marking rather than silently deleting the article. Removal of full text is reserved for exceptional legal, privacy, or safety circumstances, with a public explanatory notice where possible.

These measures follow the principles of the COPE Retraction Guidelines (reviewed 2025).

Data Availability, Reproducibility, and Confidentiality

Authors should make the evidence underlying their findings as transparent as disciplinary norms, research ethics, legal obligations, and informed consent permit. Where appropriate, manuscripts should state whether supporting data, transcriptions, interview protocols, source inventories, or analytical materials are publicly available, supplied on reasonable request, or restricted for justified ethical or legal reasons.

The journal may request confidential access to underlying materials when serious questions arise about accuracy or research integrity. No policy in this section overrides the protection of identifiable participants, unpublished archives, or culturally sensitive information.

Policy Framework

The journal’s policies are guided by recognized principles of publication ethics and transparent editorial practice. The principal framework is the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing and applicable COPE guidance. Editorial practice also remains subject to applicable law, institutional research governance, and the journal’s published author and review policies.

Related pages: Peer Review Process · Author Guidelines · Contact the Journal.