Review Process

Peer Review Model Stages of Editorial Assessment Peer Review Criteria Indicative Review Time Confidentiality, Impartiality, and Editorial Independence Editorial Decisions and Appeals

Peer Review Model

TAFSE: Journal of Qur’anic Studies applies a double-blind peer-review system: the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed during the ordinary review process. The editor selects independent reviewers with expertise relevant to the subject and method of the manuscript. The Editor-in-Chief or designated handling editor retains responsibility for the final editorial decision.

Reviewers act in an advisory capacity. Their recommendations inform but do not automatically determine acceptance, revision, or rejection. A decision must take account of the quality of the evidence, ethical requirements, the journal’s scope, and the substance of the reviews.

Stages of Editorial Assessment

  1. Submission and initial checks: OJS metadata, completeness, journal scope, originality, formatting, and anonymization are checked.
  2. Editorial screening: a qualified editor evaluates the manuscript’s research question, originality, method, scholarly merit, and potential contribution; manuscripts may be declined without external review if they do not meet the threshold.
  3. Reviewer assignment: suitable independent reviewers are invited, with attention to subject expertise, availability, and competing interests.
  4. Independent peer review: reviewers assess arguments, sources, methods, presentation, and ethical integrity and submit evidence-based recommendations.
  5. Editorial decision: the editor communicates rejection, revision requirements, further assessment, or acceptance according to the findings.
  6. Revision and reassessment: revised manuscripts are evaluated against the reviewer and editor comments and may undergo a further review round when justified.
  7. Acceptance and production: accepted manuscripts undergo editorial verification, copyediting, layout, proof review, and publication with complete metadata.

Peer Review Criteria

  • Originality and significance of the research question or argument.
  • Relevance to the Qur’an, tafsir, or an explicitly related interdisciplinary question.
  • Adequacy of theory, sources, and research methodology.
  • Accuracy and transparency in reading Qur’anic texts and interpreting classical and contemporary scholarship.
  • Coherence of evidence, argument, findings, and conclusion.
  • Appropriate engagement with prior research and accurate citation practice.
  • Ethical treatment of participants, data, and unpublished material where relevant.
  • Clarity of structure, scholarly language, and presentation.

Indicative Review Time

The journal’s existing review-process statement gives a normal period of approximately three to four months from receipt for screening and evaluation. This is an indicative interval, not a guaranteed deadline. The duration may vary with reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, revision rounds, and necessary research-integrity checks.

Confidentiality, Impartiality, and Editorial Independence

Editors and reviewers must handle unpublished submissions confidentially and declare conflicts of interest. Manuscripts authored by editorial-board members or persons with relevant relationships to an editor require independent editorial oversight and an assessment that is not preferential. Reviewer reports must be objective, specific, and professionally expressed.

Authors should not attempt to identify reviewers or interfere with their independence. The editor may seek an additional opinion when initial reviews are incomplete, contradictory, or methodologically insufficient.

Editorial Decisions and Appeals

Editorial outcomes include rejection, a request for revision, additional review, or acceptance. A request to revise does not confer a right to publication. Where possible, decision letters should give a reasoned summary of major scholarly or policy concerns. Authors may request reconsideration of material factual or procedural errors through the journal’s complaints and appeals policy.

Read also: Publication Ethics · Author Guidelines.