Peer Review Process Policy

Review model

Bunayya: Jurnal Pendidikan Anak uses double-blind peer review: the identities of the authors and the reviewers are concealed from each other during review. The process runs entirely in Open Journal Systems.

Stages

  1. Submission and editorial screening: an editor checks scope, format, and anonymisation, and runs a Turnitin similarity check (see Plagiarism Policy).
  2. Assignment: each manuscript is sent to two peer reviewers who are not members of the editorial team and who have expertise in the subject area.
  3. Review: reviewers assess the manuscript against the criteria below and submit comments and a recommendation.
  4. Editorial decision: the editor decides to accept, to request revisions, or to decline, based on the reviewers' reports and on academic merit.
  5. Revision and final decision, followed by copyediting and publication.

Time

From submission to editorial decision, the process currently takes between 25 days and five months.

Review criteria

AspectWhat reviewers check
TitleClear and informative; reflects the main finding or content.
AbstractClear and concise; states background, objective, method, main findings, and conclusion; contains no citations.
KeywordsReflect the main concepts of the article.
Novelty and gapThe introduction reviews relevant previous research, justifies the contribution, and states the research objective clearly.
Method and analysisMethod is appropriate and sufficient; findings are supported by clear data and interpreted in relation to theory and compared critically with recent, relevant studies.
ConclusionAnswers the research objective and is supported by the findings.
ReferencesAdequate in number, mainly primary sources, and current.
ScopeFits the aim and scope of the journal.
EthicsResearch involving human participants, especially children, reports ethical clearance or informed consent.
OriginalityOriginal work, with acceptable similarity.

Conduct of reviewers

Reviewers keep manuscripts confidential; review objectively and give substantive, constructive comments on the content, not only on language or layout; declare any conflict of interest (see Conflict of Interest); and do not use artificial intelligence tools in the review, including uploading a manuscript or part of it to an AI application (see Artificial Intelligence Use Policy).

The names of reviewers are listed in the overall Reviewers list only; they are not published per issue or volume, to keep the review blind.