Reviewer Guidelines

This page summarises what Bunayya: Jurnal Pendidikan Anak expects from peer reviewers. The complete process and the review criteria are given in the Peer Review Process Policy.

Before accepting an invitation

Accept only if the manuscript falls within your area of expertise and you have no conflict of interest with the authors, their institutions, or the research (see Conflict of Interest). If you cannot review the manuscript objectively or in a reasonable time, decline promptly so that another reviewer can be invited.

Confidentiality

The manuscript is a confidential document. Do not share it, discuss it with others, or use its content for your own work before it is published. The review is double-blind: do not try to identify the authors.

Conducting the review

Assess the manuscript against the criteria in the Peer Review Process Policy: title, abstract, keywords, novelty and research gap, method and analysis, conclusion, references, scope, ethics, and originality.

Give substantive and constructive comments on the content of the manuscript, not only on language or layout. Explain each criticism, point to the relevant part of the manuscript, and suggest how it can be improved. Keep the tone respectful and objective, and avoid personal remarks.

Recommendation

Submit your comments and your recommendation through the review form in Open Journal Systems. The editor makes the final decision on the basis of the reviewers' reports and academic merit.

Artificial intelligence

Do not use artificial intelligence tools in the review, and do not upload the manuscript or any part of it to an AI application. See the Artificial Intelligence Use Policy.

Suspected misconduct

If you suspect plagiarism, data fabrication, duplicate submission, or another ethical problem, inform the editor at bunayya@ar-raniry.ac.id. See Allegation of Research Misconduct.