Allegations of Research Misconduct

DAYAH: Journal of Islamic Education receives and evaluates credible concerns relating to submitted and published scholarship. Concerns may involve fabrication or falsification of data, invented quotations or interviews, plagiarism, citation manipulation, unauthorized use of personal information, manipulation of peer review, inappropriate authorship practices, or unethical research involving participants.

Handling of allegations

  1. Allegations are submitted to the editorial office with an identification of the work concerned and, where available, supporting evidence.
  2. The Editor-in-Chief or a non-conflicted editor conducts a preliminary assessment of whether investigation is warranted.
  3. Relevant parties are informed of substantive concerns and given an opportunity to respond. Manuscripts, correspondence, and identities are handled confidentially to the extent compatible with fair investigation.
  4. Where research records, institutional authority, or expertise are required, the journal may contact the relevant institution or an appropriately independent expert.
  5. Possible outcomes include closure with no action, requests for clarification, rejection, correction, expression of concern, retraction, or institutional referral, according to the evidence and seriousness of the issue.

Allegations are not treated as findings of misconduct. Editorial responses are proportionate, documented, and guided by relevant COPE guidance. Financial or personal relationships must not influence the outcome.

DAYAH: Journal of Islamic Education · Master’s Program in Islamic Education, Graduate School, UIN Ar-Raniry · jie@ar-raniry.ac.id