Peer Review Process

1. Double-Blind Peer Review Model

JIIF employs a double-blind peer-review model for original research articles. Authors' identities are concealed from reviewers, while reviewers' identities are concealed from authors throughout the evaluation process.

Authors must submit an anonymized manuscript without identifying information, including names, institutional affiliations, email addresses, ORCID identifiers, acknowledgments, and identifying document metadata. Author information is provided separately as required by the journal's submission guidelines.

Editorials, book reviews, and other non-research content, where published, may follow editorial assessment procedures appropriate to their publication type. Any exception to the standard external peer-review process must be accurately identified.

2. Initial Editorial Screening

All submitted manuscripts undergo initial editorial screening to determine their relevance to the journal's focus and scope, originality, scholarly contribution, methodological adequacy, ethical compliance, and conformity with the Author Guidelines.

Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's requirements may be returned for preliminary revision or rejected without external review. Manuscripts that pass screening proceed to independent peer review. Compliance with technical submission requirements does not guarantee acceptance for external review.

3. Reviewer Selection and Responsibilities

Manuscripts selected for peer review are evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with expertise relevant to the subject, research methodology, and scholarly context of the manuscript.

Reviewers are selected by the responsible editor based on academic expertise, independence, and the absence of relevant conflicts of interest. Additional reviewers may be invited when specialized assessment or further independent evaluation is necessary.

Reviewers must provide objective, constructive, evidence-based evaluations, maintain manuscript confidentiality, and declare any circumstances that could compromise their impartiality. They must not use unpublished materials for personal advantage or attempt to influence the editorial process through inappropriate citation demands or other misconduct.

4. Review Assessment and Reporting Methods

Reviewers assess manuscripts based on originality, scholarly significance, theoretical and methodological rigor, appropriateness of sources, quality of evidence, analytical depth, research ethics, clarity of presentation, and contribution to the relevant field of scholarship.

JIIF provides a structured reviewer form through Open Journal Systems (OJS) to facilitate consistent assessment. Reviewers may also provide substantive comments directly within the manuscript using annotations, document comments, or tracked changes. An annotated manuscript may be uploaded through the OJS review workflow, either as a supplementary review document or alongside the assigned review form.

Where completion of the reviewer form is required for a particular assignment, reviewers must complete the form even when providing additional manuscript annotations. Reviewers must submit their evaluation and recommendation through the designated OJS review process.

Review reports should identify substantive strengths and weaknesses, explain the reasons for requested changes, and provide actionable recommendations. Reviewers may distinguish comments intended for authors from confidential information intended exclusively for editors.

Before annotated files are shared with authors, reviewer-identifying information, including names in document properties, comments, and tracked changes, must be removed. The responsible editor determines which review materials are appropriate for communication to the authors while preserving reviewer confidentiality.

5. Editorial Decisions, Revisions, and Review Timeline

Following peer review, the Editor-in-Chief or designated handling editor evaluates the reviewers' recommendations and the manuscript's scholarly merits before making an editorial decision. Possible outcomes include acceptance, minor revision, major revision or resubmission for further review, and rejection.

Reviewers provide recommendations, while responsibility for the editorial decision rests with the journal's authorized editor. Where reviewer assessments differ substantially, the editor may seek additional independent evaluation.

Authors invited to revise must submit a revised manuscript accompanied by a point-by-point response addressing the substantive comments of reviewers and editors. Authors may provide reasoned scholarly explanations when they disagree with particular recommendations. Major revisions may undergo an additional round of external review.

Review and revision deadlines are communicated through the OJS editorial workflow. The overall duration may vary depending on reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, revision requirements, and additional review rounds. Authors are informed of significant delays through the journal's official editorial communication channels. An invitation to revise does not guarantee acceptance.

6. Confidentiality, Editorial Independence, and Appeals

All participants in the peer-review process must protect confidential manuscript information and respect applicable conflicts-of-interest requirements. Reviewers must not disclose or circulate unpublished manuscripts, share confidential content with unauthorized individuals or external AI services, or communicate directly with authors without editorial authorization.

Editorial decisions must remain independent of authors' institutional affiliations, personal relationships, financial considerations, publication fees, or inappropriate external influence. Manuscripts involving editors or other individuals with potential conflicts of interest must be managed by appropriately unconflicted editorial personnel.

Authors may appeal an editorial decision when they identify a material factual error, procedural irregularity, relevant conflict of interest, or substantial evidence that was not appropriately considered. Appeals are assessed by an unconflicted editor where practicable. Allegations of peer-review misconduct are addressed under the journal's Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement.