Research Data, Transparency and Reproducibility

1. Research Transparency and Supporting Evidence

Authors must accurately describe the research design, sources of evidence, data collection or selection procedures, analytical methods, and processes used to develop their findings. The information provided must be sufficient for readers and reviewers to evaluate the reliability and validity of the research.

Research data and supporting evidence may include quantitative datasets, interview transcripts, field notes, research instruments, archival documents, manuscripts, textual sources, coding records, analytical scripts, and other materials relevant to the study. The type and extent of documentation required depend on the research methodology and disciplinary context.

JIIF recognizes that reproducibility takes different forms across research traditions. Quantitative and computational studies may support reproducibility through documented data and analytical procedures, while qualitative, historical, and interpretive studies must provide sufficient methodological and evidentiary transparency to support independent scholarly examination.

2. Data Availability Statement

All original research articles must include a Data Availability Statement explaining the availability of research data and supporting materials relevant to the reported findings. This requirement also applies to studies based exclusively on existing publications, historical sources, or conceptual and textual analysis.

The statement must indicate, as applicable:

  • Whether supporting data or research materials are publicly available, available upon reasonable request, or subject to restricted access.
  • The repository name, persistent identifier, or stable URL when data have been deposited.
  • Relevant ethical, legal, confidentiality, or institutional restrictions affecting access.
  • Whether the study relies on existing published sources without generating a new research dataset.

Data Availability Statements must accurately reflect the actual status of research materials. Authors must not claim public deposit or availability upon request unless an appropriate access arrangement exists. The statement must be included in the manuscript declarations according to the official JIIF template.

3. Responsible Data Sharing and Access Restrictions

JIIF encourages authors to deposit shareable research data in appropriate institutional, disciplinary, or general-purpose repositories that provide reliable access, sufficient metadata, and persistent identifiers. Data sharing should follow the principles of Findability, Accessibility, Interoperability, and Reusability (FAIR) where relevant.

Public disclosure is not required when it would violate participant consent, privacy, confidentiality, copyright, archival permissions, institutional agreements, or other legitimate restrictions. Such limitations may apply to identifiable interview records, sensitive fieldwork information, restricted archives, unpublished manuscripts, and protected cultural materials.

Where open access is inappropriate, authors must explain the restrictions in their Data Availability Statement. Anonymized excerpts, aggregated information, methodological documentation, or controlled access may be provided when ethically and legally permissible. The journal does not require unrestricted disclosure of confidential research materials as a condition of publication.

4. Evidence Requirements Across Research Approaches

Qualitative and fieldwork research. Authors must describe relevant participant or source selection procedures, data collection methods, analytical processes, and the relationship between empirical evidence and findings. Interview quotations must accurately represent the original records. Confidential transcripts and identifiable field notes must be protected in accordance with research-ethics obligations.

Religious, textual, and historical research. Authors must accurately identify primary sources, manuscripts, textual editions, translations, archival collections, and other documentary evidence. Relevant page, folio, section, or manuscript identifiers should be provided where available. Interpretive conclusions must be distinguishable from original source material, and translations or textual reconstructions must not be misrepresented as authentic verbatim quotations.

Quantitative and computational research. Authors must report relevant sampling procedures, variable definitions, research instruments, data preparation, statistical methods, analytical assumptions, and software information. Supporting datasets, code, or analytical documentation should be made available where appropriate and permitted by applicable ethical, legal, and institutional requirements.

5. Data Integrity, Retention, and Editorial Verification

Authors are responsible for the accuracy, provenance, and integrity of their research data and supporting evidence. Fabrication, falsification, misleading alteration, and misrepresentation of research materials are prohibited. Relevant data processing, transcription, translation, coding, and analytical decisions must be documented where they materially affect the findings.

Authors must retain relevant research records securely in accordance with applicable institutional policies, research-ethics approvals, funding agreements, legal obligations, and disciplinary standards. Confidential and sensitive materials must be protected against unauthorized access, disclosure, or misuse.

Editors may request reasonable clarification or supporting documentation when substantive concerns arise regarding research evidence, analytical procedures, or reported findings. Such requests must respect legitimate confidentiality and access restrictions, and alternative verification arrangements may be considered where appropriate.

Significant errors or suspected data misconduct are addressed through JIIF's applicable publication ethics and post-publication procedures. Authors must cooperate with legitimate research-integrity inquiries and promptly report material errors that could affect the reliability of published findings.

6. Examples of Data Availability Statements

The following examples illustrate Data Availability Statements for different research designs. Authors must adapt the wording to their actual research materials and access conditions.

6.1 Publicly Available Data

The data supporting the findings of this study are available in [REPOSITORY NAME] at [DOI OR STABLE URL].

6.2 Data Available on Reasonable Request

The research data supporting this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request, subject to applicable ethical and institutional requirements.

6.3 Confidential Qualitative Data

The interview transcripts and fieldwork records are not publicly available due to participant confidentiality and informed consent restrictions. Relevant anonymized evidence is included in the article where ethically appropriate.

6.4 Historical and Archival Materials

This study draws on historical and archival materials identified in the References and source descriptions. Access to certain original records is governed by the relevant archives or holding institutions.

6.5 Research Using Published Sources

No new empirical dataset was generated for this study. The research is based on published literature and documentary sources identified in the References.

6.6 Mixed-Methods Research

The quantitative dataset is available at [REPOSITORY OR ACCESS INFORMATION]. Qualitative interview materials are not publicly available because of participant confidentiality and applicable research-ethics restrictions.

These examples are illustrative and must not be used where they misrepresent the existence, accessibility, or permitted use of research materials.