Complaints and Appeals Policy

1. Scope of Complaints

JIIF accepts complaints concerning editorial procedures, peer-review conduct, unreasonable editorial delays, breaches of confidentiality, unfair treatment, conflicts of interest, and other matters relating to the responsibilities of the journal, its editors, reviewers, staff, or publisher.

Complaints concerning suspected research misconduct or the reliability of published articles are handled under the journal's separate research-integrity and post-publication policies.

2. Submission and Acknowledgment

Complaints and appeals may be submitted to the editorial office at islamfutura@ar-raniry.ac.id. Authors may also use the official OJS editorial correspondence system for concerns relating to an active manuscript.

Submissions should identify the relevant manuscript, editorial decision, or publication; clearly explain the concern; and provide supporting correspondence, documentation, or evidence where available.

The journal acknowledges receipt of complaints and appeals, maintains an appropriate record, and arranges an impartial assessment. Correspondence is handled confidentially to the extent practicable.

3. Appeals Against Editorial Decisions

Authors may appeal an editorial decision when they identify a material factual error, procedural irregularity, relevant conflict of interest, or significant evidence that was not appropriately considered during the original assessment.

Appeals must state the specific grounds for reconsideration. Disagreement with a reviewer's scholarly judgment, without substantive supporting grounds, does not by itself justify reopening an editorial decision.

Where practicable, appeals are assessed by an editor who was not responsible for the original decision and has no relevant conflict of interest. Additional independent scholarly advice may be obtained when necessary. An appeal does not guarantee reversal of the original decision or acceptance for publication.

4. Independent Assessment, Resolution, and Escalation

Complaints are assessed using relevant editorial records and available evidence. Affected parties are given an appropriate opportunity to respond where necessary. Individuals directly involved in the complaint or affected by a relevant conflict of interest must not determine its outcome.

Depending on the findings, the journal may uphold the original decision, correct a procedural error, arrange an independent reassessment, provide clarification, or take other appropriate action within its editorial responsibilities.

Complaints involving the Editor-in-Chief or unresolved concerns about journal management may be referred to an unconflicted representative of the publisher, the Center for Research and Publication (LP2M), UIN Ar-Raniry, or an appropriate university authority. Where the publisher itself is implicated, assessment must be referred to an authority independent of the matter under consideration.

JIIF communicates the outcome and relevant reasons to the complainant, maintains appropriate records, and does not tolerate retaliation against individuals raising concerns in good faith.