Post-Publication Discussion

1. Scholarly Dialogue After Publication

JIIF welcomes scholarly comments concerning the methodology, evidence, interpretation, findings, and conclusions of published articles. Such contributions may offer alternative perspectives, identify limitations, or provide additional evidence relevant to the original research.

Constructive academic disagreement is recognized as a legitimate part of scholarly discourse and does not, by itself, constitute research misconduct.

2. Submission of Scholarly Comments

Readers may submit scholarly comments or critiques to the editorial office at islamfutura@ar-raniry.ac.id. Submissions should identify the relevant published article, provide its DOI or permanent URL, and clearly explain the points raised.

Comments must be supported by appropriate scholarly reasoning, references, or evidence. Personal attacks, discriminatory statements, defamatory allegations, and unauthorized disclosure of confidential information are not acceptable.

3. Editorial Assessment and Author Response

The editorial team assesses submitted comments for scholarly relevance, evidentiary support, and suitability for academic discussion. The original authors may be invited to respond, and independent expert assessment may be sought when necessary.

Substantive critiques and author responses may be considered for publication as scholarly correspondence, subject to editorial approval and the journal's applicable publication arrangements. Where published, such exchanges are clearly identified and linked to the original article.

Concerns involving material errors or suspected research misconduct are addressed under JIIF's separate Correction and Retraction Policy or Allegations of Research Misconduct Policy, as appropriate.