Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statements

1. General Ethical Principles

JIIF upholds honesty, originality, accountability, fairness, confidentiality, transparency, and respect for intellectual property throughout manuscript submission, editorial evaluation, peer review, publication, and post-publication management.

All participants in scholarly publishing must act professionally, respect academic freedom, and avoid discrimination, harassment, coercion, manipulation, or improper influence. Scholarly judgments must be grounded in evidence and academic merit rather than personal, institutional, political, religious, or financial interests.

These principles apply to all submissions and published content. The journal's specific editorial policies establish the corresponding requirements, safeguards, and procedures.

2. Responsibilities of Editors and the Publisher

Editorial independence. The Editor-in-Chief and authorized handling editors are responsible for editorial decisions. Manuscripts must be evaluated according to scholarly merit, originality, methodological quality, ethical compliance, and relevance to the journal's scope. Publication fees, sponsorship, institutional influence, or external pressure must not determine editorial acceptance.

Fairness and confidentiality. Editors must assess manuscripts impartially, safeguard unpublished material and confidential editorial communications, manage competing interests, and refrain from exploiting information obtained through their editorial responsibilities. Editors with material conflicts of interest must withdraw from handling the affected submissions.

Publisher responsibility. JIIF is published by the Center for Research and Publication, Institute for Research and Community Service (LP2M), Universitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry Banda Aceh, Indonesia. The publisher supports academic freedom, editorial independence, transparent governance, responsible management of ethical concerns, and the long-term integrity of published scholarship.

Related policies: Conflicts of Interest Policy | Ownership and Management | Article Processing Charges Policy

3. Peer Review Integrity and Reviewer Responsibilities

JIIF applies double-blind peer review to original research articles. Reviewers are selected according to relevant expertise and independence and must provide objective, constructive, and evidence-based assessments. Scholarly criticism must address the manuscript rather than the author's personal characteristics or presumed identity.

Reviewers must maintain confidentiality, disclose relevant competing interests, and decline assignments when their expertise or impartiality is insufficient. They must not appropriate unpublished research, manipulate citations, disclose confidential information, or exploit the review process for personal or professional advantage.

Reviewer recommendations inform editorial decisions but do not replace the independent judgment of the responsible editor. The detailed reviewer selection, assessment methods, reporting procedures, revision process, and editorial decision pathway are governed by the journal's Peer Review Process.

Related policy: Peer Review Process

4. Author Responsibilities and Research Integrity

Authors must report their research honestly and accurately, distinguish evidence from interpretation, and ensure that findings and conclusions reflect the research actually conducted. Fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, deceptive presentation of evidence, invented references, misleading quotations, and citation manipulation are prohibited.

Submitted manuscripts must constitute original scholarly contributions, appropriately acknowledge the work of others, and provide accurate and traceable sources. Concurrent submission and undisclosed redundant publication are unacceptable. Translations of previously published works are not accepted as new original research articles under the journal's applicable Author Guidelines.

Authorship must reflect genuine intellectual contribution, approval of the submitted work, and accountability for the research. Gift, honorary, guest, and ghost authorship are prohibited. All listed authors must agree to the authorship arrangements and cooperate in resolving legitimate questions concerning the integrity of their work.

Authors must provide accurate research documentation, acknowledge relevant limitations, respect third-party intellectual-property rights, and cooperate with reasonable editorial requests for clarification or verification. Detailed requirements for authorship, originality, similarity screening, and manuscript preparation are established in the journal's dedicated policies and Author Guidelines.

Related policies: Authorship and Contributorship Policy | Plagiarism Policy | Author Guidelines

5. Ethical Oversight and Protection of Research Participants

Research involving human participants, interviews, surveys, ethnographic observation, oral histories, personal information, or identifiable communities must comply with applicable ethical, legal, and institutional requirements. Authors must obtain ethics approval or an appropriate exemption where required and accurately describe the ethical procedures applicable to the study.

Researchers must respect informed consent, voluntary participation, privacy, confidentiality, and protection against foreseeable harm. Particular care is required in studies involving children, vulnerable individuals, sensitive information, or communities whose identification may expose participants to personal, social, or institutional risks.

Research involving religious manuscripts, archival documents, oral traditions, sacred texts, cultural heritage, and community knowledge must respect applicable access conditions, permissions, cultural responsibilities, and intellectual-property rights. Researchers must accurately identify, quote, translate, contextualize, and interpret relevant source materials using appropriate scholarly methods.

JIIF supports critical academic inquiry and legitimate differences in scholarly interpretation. Ethical oversight must protect research participants and source materials without preventing evidence-based criticism or reasoned academic disagreement.

6. Research Transparency, Declarations, and Responsible AI Use

Research data and reproducibility. Authors must describe their sources, research procedures, and analytical methods sufficiently to support critical scholarly evaluation. Original research articles must include an accurate Data Availability Statement under the journal's Research Data Policy. Legitimate restrictions on access to confidential, sensitive, archival, or third-party materials must be respected.

Funding and competing interests. Authors must identify research funding sources, disclose the role of sponsors where applicable, and declare financial and non-financial interests that could reasonably influence, or appear to influence, the research. Reviewers and editors are subject to corresponding disclosure and independence requirements.

Generative artificial intelligence. AI systems cannot be designated as authors. Human researchers remain responsible for the accuracy, originality, interpretation, and integrity of their work. AI assistance must be disclosed and documented in accordance with the journal's Generative AI Policy. Confidential manuscript materials must not be exposed through unauthorized AI use during peer review or editorial evaluation.

Related policies: Research Data Policy| Conflicts of Interest Policy | Generative AI Policy

7. Allegations of Misconduct, Complaints, and Fair Procedures

JIIF takes credible concerns about research and publication misconduct seriously, whether they arise before or after publication. Such concerns may involve unreliable research evidence, plagiarism, unethical research, authorship abuse, citation manipulation, compromised peer review, or other conduct affecting publication integrity.

Concerns may be reported through the journal's official editorial channels, including islamfutura@ar-raniry.ac.id. Allegations must be assessed according to available evidence, with appropriate confidentiality, management of conflicts of interest, and a fair opportunity for affected parties to respond. Matters requiring institutional investigation may be referred to the competent authority.

Complaints concerning editorial conduct and appeals against editorial decisions are handled through separate procedures. Editorial measures must be proportionate, documented, and based on substantiated concerns rather than unsupported allegations. Retaliation against individuals reporting concerns in good faith is unacceptable.

Related policies: Research Misconduct Policy | Complaints and Appeals Policy

8. Post-Publication Accountability and the Scholarly Record

JIIF encourages constructive, evidence-based discussion of published research and maintains procedures for addressing substantive errors or concerns affecting the reliability of scholarly publications.

Depending on the evidence and significance of the issue, appropriate editorial action may include a correction, expression of concern, or retraction. Such actions must be transparent, clearly identified, and linked to the affected publication. Retracted articles normally remain accessible with an explicit indication of their status, except where exceptional legal, safety, or privacy considerations justify removal.

JIIF respects intellectual-property rights and provides open access to its published scholarship. Copyright ownership, licensing conditions, repository sharing, and permissions for reuse are governed by the applicable publication license and the journal's separate policies. The integrity and accessibility of the scholarly record must be preserved through responsible editorial and publisher oversight.

Related policies: Correction and Retraction Policy | Post-Publication Discussion Policy | Copyright and Licensing Policy | Open Access Policy