Allegations of Research Misconduct

1. Reportable Research and Publication Misconduct

JIIF considers credible allegations involving research data fabrication or falsification, plagiarism, duplicate publication, inappropriate authorship, citation manipulation, peer-review manipulation, misleading affiliations, undisclosed conflicts of interest, unethical research practices, and other serious breaches of publication integrity.

Concerns may involve authors, reviewers, editors, or other participants in the publication process. Allegations concerning submitted and published works are assessed according to the same principles of fairness, evidence, and editorial accountability.

2. Reporting Allegations

Concerns about suspected misconduct may be submitted to the JIIF editorial office at islamfutura@ar-raniry.ac.id. Reports should identify the relevant manuscript or publication, explain the nature of the concern, and provide supporting evidence where available.

Reports are handled confidentially to the extent practicable. Credible anonymous allegations may also be considered when supported by verifiable information. The journal assesses allegations on their merits and does not treat unsubstantiated claims as established misconduct.

3. Preliminary Assessment and Fair Procedure

An editor without a relevant conflict of interest conducts a preliminary assessment of the allegation and available evidence. Where further inquiry is warranted, the affected author or other relevant party is informed of the substantive concerns and given an appropriate opportunity to respond.

The journal may seek additional documentation or independent expert advice. Cases requiring investigation of underlying research conduct, institutional records, or matters beyond the journal's authority may be referred to the relevant institution, research ethics body, or other competent organization.

The process must be impartial, documented, and proportionate to the concerns raised. Individuals with relevant conflicts of interest must not control the assessment. Where an allegation concerns an editor, responsibility for handling the matter is assigned to an appropriately unconflicted representative of the journal or publisher.

4. Editorial Outcomes and Scholarly Record

Depending on the evidence and seriousness of the concern, JIIF may close the matter without further action, request clarification or correction, suspend editorial processing, reject a manuscript, or refer the case for institutional investigation.

For published articles, appropriate measures may include a correction, expression of concern, or retraction in accordance with the journal's post-publication policies and applicable COPE guidance. Public notices must accurately explain the status of the publication and remain linked to the scholarly record.

Material decisions and supporting evidence are documented. Editorial actions are based on verified findings and the reliability of the publication, with due regard for procedural fairness, confidentiality, and the rights of affected parties.